SARACENS v LEICESTER please add match related content here
By Monaghan Boy
November 2 2023
Finally. Back to winning ways, the men in black return to north London following a remarkably dominant display at Gloucester’s Kingsholm. Key performers Tom Willis and Andy Christie stood out, as they have done for much of the start of the campaign, and will surely look to kick on this weekend.
Also one from three, however, and without a raft of internationals… Leicester Tigers await.
Last season’s fixture was, perhaps, the home team’s most dominant North London performance - the bonus point secured before half time, with tries from Alex Lozowski, Ben Earl, Max Malins and Ivan Van Zyl, in what was an attacking masterclass masterminded by Owen Farrell and Elliott Daly. With limited attacking success in recent weeks, Saracens will look to impress home fans with a return to expansive rugby, exploiting Saturday’s conveniently forecasted break in rain around kick off.
Three of those star names may well return this week, following World Cup duty with England, and, if social media videos are any evidence, then all involved seem raring to feature. New faces Lucio Cinti and Juan Martin Gonzales could make their first appearances, but after a heavy World Cup campaign, with little rotation, are surely in need of rest. In the Tigers camp, fellow Argentinian Julian Montoya, similarly integral to a fatigued Pumas side, could also sit out. Theo Dan and Billy Vunipola both enjoyed only limited game time in France, so could be expected to feature from the off this weekend. An out of form Vunipola may struggle to retake his long held 8 shirt from newcomer Willis this season, the latter perhaps shifting to 6 in the absence of an injured Nick Isiekwe.
Owen Farrell and Ben Earl could be forgiven for exhaustion following their mighty World Cup efforts, but the leadership of either one would be a monumental boost to the Saracens staring XV. Similarly, Elliot Daly, an integral piece of Saracens backline for much of last season, returns to the club with a fortnight’s rest, and could replace stalwart Alex Goode in the 15 shirt following a lacklustre start to the season.
Tigers too could bolster their squad with World Cup returnees. Locks Chessum and Martin rotated in the closing weeks of the tournament, so could feature in a heavy Tigers pack. Equally, Dan Cole’s week on the bench could see him straight back in a green and red jersey, taking the place of Joe Heyes, while Freddie Steward finds competition from Mike Brown for a second season. Ex-Worcesterman Jamie Shillcock has been given the keys at 10 over the past fortnight, and, assuming the continued absence of World Cup Champion Handre Pollard, will be looking to steer the Leicester outfit to back-to-back wins on the road.
Likewise, ex-Saracen Tom Whiteley could make a third successive start, as they await the return of Ben Youngs and Jack Van Poortvliet from international duty and injury respectively. Regardless of selection and performance, both sides will be eager to find a winning habit after shaky opening fortnights.
Thread merged with earlier thread about team selection for the sake of clarity
Glos match report should be coming soon - delayed due to ill health of metch reporter
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2023:11:15:17:17:49 by Darraghgirl.
1. Eroni
2. Dan
3. Marco R
4. Tiz
5. Hunter Hill (/Nick I if back to fitness)
6. Tom Willis
7. Andy C
8. Billy V
9. Ivan
10. Manu (Feel like Faz needs a weekends rest)
11. Daly
12. Nick T
13. Loz.
14. Lewi
15. Goode
16. Hadfield / Woolf
17. Mako
18. Judge
19. Theo Mac / Callum HH
20. Gonzalez
21. Simpson (Please please not Davies)
22. Cinti
23. Matiland
I’d consider resting Nick T perhaps, especially if Faz is back to help guide Hartley.
I’d also say Clarey has been our best tighthead this season so far, so would like to see him get a start post injury.
Obviously the coaches and players will decide which returning players will come straight back and it would be good to put out a strong team after the loss at home to Bath. I think both McFarland and Isiewkwe (failed HIA) are still unavailable but I'm not positive.
My feeling is that since the horrendous opening game away to Chiefs the team have been steadily improving. The huge take-away from that game was don't kick long to a team who want to counter-attack and have very fast, steppy runners. It's not a lesson we learnt for Bath but against Glaws it was better. I'm much happier with a kick to compete game but there must be a reason we're not doing that?
It's too early in the season to judge the new players but I felt Hadfield had a great game against Glaws after his start against Bath. As others said above Clarey coming on seemed to have a big impact at scrum time too. Davies has had a mixed bag but was excellent against Glaws in defence especially (as was Goode) for this game I'd be happy with him on the bench.
Unless T Willis wants/needs a break I wouldn't move him from 8. Billy on the bench for me and lets see the sort of performance he couldn't deliver at the RWC before he walks back into the starting team.
Mawi, Dan, Riccioni, CH-H, Tizard, Christie, Knight, T Willis, IVZ, Farrell(c) Lewington, Tompkins, Lozo, Daly, Goode.
West, Hadfield, Clarey, Pearce-Paul, Billy, Davies, Hartley, Maitland.
I've only seen the Bath game which took me back to dark days at Vicarage Road.
I just want the coaches to pick the players who are ready and rest the ones who need a break.
Looking forward to my Saturday!
Successful hills are here to stay
Everything must be this way
Gentle streets where people play
Welcome to the Soft Parade
🌻🌻🌻
1 Mako Vunipola
2 Jamie George
3 Marco Riccioni
4 Maro Itoje
5 Nick Isiekwe
6 Andy Christie
7 Ben Earl
8 Billy Vunipola
9 Aled Davies
10 Owen Farrell (c)
11 Elliot Daly
12 Nick Tompkins
13 Alex Lozowski
14 Sean Maitland
15 Alex Goode
Replacements:
16 Theo Dan
17 Eroni Mawi
18 Alec Clarey
19 Callum Hunter-Hill
20 Hugh Tizard
21 Tom Willis
22 Ivan van Zyl
23 Tom Parton
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2023:11:03:12:01:34 by Sarriebone.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2023:11:03:12:05:06 by Sarriebone.

Referee: Craig Maxwell-Keys
ARs: Joe James & Peter Allan
TMO: Rowan Kitt
We’re probably only missing Theo M, JMG and Cinti from our first choice 23.
Hopefully 5 points, but I imagine they’ll be some rust for the returning players to shake off too.
I didn’t hear it but apparently there was a bit about his surgery on radio 4 this week
home alone with boy.... cheer for meNinjafez - supporting Sarries and cleaning their signs since 2006!
Quote:Stopsy
Kata also featured in the RWC. I’ll be interested to see how we go against such a strong selection.
Yes, but on the bench so might not take part, or for long ?
Quote:The Bard
So Nick Isiekwe obviously didn’t fail an HIA last Friday.
I didn’t hear it but apparently there was a bit about his surgery on radio 4 this week
Caught the end of it. Apparently it was quite random that he ended up at the hospital pioneering the treatment he had. If he’d gone somewhere else he would have had a heart stent which would have finished his career.
but the forecast suggests we might get a little window to play some rugby tomorrow and lets hope for some fireworks on the field as well as off it after!
A bit like last week the opposition have probably gone weaker than we might have expected but I'm sure there will be no complacency about the threat Tigers can offer or the result. Shillcock was excellent last week, arguably the better 10 on the field (which given the other was Baths £1M?-man Finn Russell is quite an eye-opener) in poor conditions he had them playing in the right areas of the field and kicked brilliantly. An interesting head-to-head from the bench too with returning International Theo Dan up against the very good Nic Dolly who excepting injury could quite possibly have been in contention for the RWC squad.
Expecting big performances from the Vunipolae as they have been backed with the starts. Great bench to come on and make an impact. Time to get the winning show back on the road at home.
Quote:Duncan96
Apparently it was quite random that he ended up at the hospital pioneering the treatment he had. If he’d gone somewhere else he would have had a heart stent which would have finished his career.
An incredible story and brilliant for Isiekwe, huge credit to his surgeon and ofc great that we get to continue to see him at Sarries.
Hopefully we have a great game (although not too great for the visitors!)
Interested where you see JMG and Cinti in first choice 23 Dolph? Agree about McFarland.
Quote:Duncan96Quote:The Bard
So Nick Isiekwe obviously didn’t fail an HIA last Friday.
I didn’t hear it but apparently there was a bit about his surgery on radio 4 this week
Caught the end of it. Apparently it was quite random that he ended up at the hospital pioneering the treatment he had. If he’d gone somewhere else he would have had a heart stent which would have finished his career.
I missed it live but caught up on i-player. To be honest it was more about the innovative surgery than Nick himself, but obviously he's a very notable example of the success of an approach that could benefit many more people if more surgeons and hospitals adopted it.
There should be only one side in it this afternoon but given how bloodyminded Tigers are these days nothing can be taken for granted. It should make interesting watching.
I believe both Vunipolae had a +1 clause that they exercised and the club accepted, Maitland was offered an additional year and Goode two. No one can fight the march of time but I think the club has done pretty well in bringing in players to replace those. T Willis was the clubs big signing for this season and already looks to the Manor born. LH and Utility back(s) also have good cover although getting players to match any of those in their prime would obviously be difficult.
My feeling (hope) is those mentioned will increasingly be part of a strong bench this season rather than starters. Injuries and International call-ups (the down side of all those Internationals) mean that theoretically those more senior players will be very useful as long as they still play with some of their historical form. I guess we'll see. One thing that seems clear is a big chunk of Salary Cap will be freed next season and I'm intrigued as to what players might join (and hopeful it won't just mean all that money is spent increasing the salaries of current players)
I've said on your forum several times I'm interested/excited by what Baxter is doing at Chiefs and whilst I think retaining core players and coaches to provide stability and continuity is a key part of success (as you showed in your Premiership and the double winning period) there is no doubt there's an attraction in ripping it all down and starting again.
Chiefs look great this season and whilst they'll find it tougher as they play increasingly full opposition teams you must be delighted with how the future looks.
I was pretty sanguine about this season but have been delighted at performances so far, although gutted by the horrid injury to Hodge at Quins , where nothing quite went right. The really pleasing thing apart from the emotional energy snap and snarl about the team, is the sense of balance you feel. It is a quality in my opinion usually impossible to achieve by choice, but often resulting from serendipity. Long may it continue. Another real test today but I have a quiet confidence about our mishmash of one cap wonders, misfits, castoffs and kids!
Quote:Old Marovian
to the Manor born.[email][/email]
I did enjoy this. The original wording is "Although I am a native here, and to the manner born". (King Lear, Act iv Scene 1) 'To the Manor born' was the pun title of the wonderful Penelope Keith series on TV. However, Shakespeare was perfectly capable of introducing puns into his plays, so it may be that his was the derivative and yours a reference to an older usage of the pronounced word.
Innings
Points win matches: tries win hearts and minds.
But surely the big highlight was having Dolly and Parton on the pitch at the same time?
Again, I thought Aled was exceptional. Every box kick was on the money, and I'd even say our tempo suffered when he went off. Daly looked class in the first half, but we didn't seem to bring him into the game in the second.
Quote:MonaghanBoy
Fantastic performance, although I thought we fizzled out a little in the second half. Individually, Maro was incredible and was rightly deserving of MOTM, and Big Nick was exceptional in the lineout.
Again, I thought Aled was exceptional. Every box kick was on the money, and I'd even say our tempo suffered when he went off. Daly looked class in the first half, but we didn't seem to bring him into the game in the second.
Agree with all of that, plus a big shout out to Christie and our own bomb squad who made a difference to the scrum when they came on. Hope Eroni is ok, looked like an arm or rib injury (he was holding his arm to his rib, so who knows?!), I think he deserves to start over Mako at the moment (if fit).
On the positive side it's a desperately needed 5 points, the result was never in doubt (as it shouldn't have been given the two contrasting sides) and hopefully Mawi is ok and we picked up no injuries.
A number of the pack had exceptional games and we had a glimpse into how good this team could be. As mentioned Maro looked incredible and how Sarries took Tigers apart at lineout was delicious (imagine McFarland competing too) it also felt like we kept hold of the ball more too. Billy had an ok game and I hope he rediscovers his form of last season.
Agree with JimG that the attack stuttered and whilst you often see that when reintegrating players I had hoped with this core group so familiar with each other it might look more fluid but that's something that will surely come.
We have an obvious issue at scrum time and dependant on injuries an obvious solution. Performance before reputation and the change with a sub was very obvious.
A short kicking game is excellent used as part of an attacking plan or in ideal circumstances but not deployed (what felt like) almost continuously. Feels like Borthwick has taught Farrell some bad habits!
Speaking of which not a good game by him. Would be interesting to see the comments had that been Manu in that full squad. Responsible for both of their trys and wasteful of some of our better possession. I'm not sure who in the squad gives him a rocket but someone needs to after that performance.
The win was great. Some of the potential shown was exceptional. Still lots of work to do and I'd guess a fair few players will need a rest now.
That first try was a scintillating example of what this team can do at their best. Play at tempo, keep the ball, great support lines and skills, a real joy to watch. I'd love them to embrace that style more as they did at the end of last season.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2023:11:05:10:21:54 by OldMarovian.
Speaking of which not a good game by him. Would be interesting to see the comments had that been Manu in that full squad. Responsible for both of their trys and wasteful of some of our better possession. I'm not sure who in the squad gives him a rocket but someone needs to after that performance.
I very much doubt anyone will need to give him a rocket (although I'd pay good money to watch you try OM). He will know it wasn't his finest day at the office. He would also probably tell you it was the execution that was at fault rather than the tactic.

Quote:Innings
I did enjoy this. The original wording is "Although I am a native here, and to the manner born". (King Lear, Act iv Scene 1) 'To the Manor born' was the pun title of the wonderful Penelope Keith series on TV. However, Shakespeare was perfectly capable of introducing puns into his plays, so it may be that his was the derivative and yours a reference to an older usage of the pronounced word.
You learn something new everyday! I was neither familiar with the original wording or realised that the comedy title was a play on words.
Innings
Points win matches: tries win hearts and minds.
Then once the TBP was secured, Farrell could take the Penalty kicks and keep a comfortable lead!
Quote:OldMarovian
Agree with JimG that the attack stuttered and whilst you often see that when reintegrating players I had hoped with this core group so familiar with each other it might look more fluid but that's something that will surely come.
We have an obvious issue at scrum time and dependant on injuries an obvious solution. Performance before reputation and the change with a sub was very obvious.
A short kicking game is excellent used as part of an attacking plan or in ideal circumstances but not deployed (what felt like) almost continuously. Feels like Borthwick has taught Farrell some bad habits!
Speaking of which not a good game by him. Would be interesting to see the comments had that been Manu in that full squad. Responsible for both of their trys and wasteful of some of our better possession. I'm not sure who in the squad gives him a rocket but someone needs to after that performance
I think the kicking game was a result of a few things. Firstly the cohesion wasn’t there, as has been pointed out a lot, for example it looked like Loz in particular was out of sync with the rest a few times, totally understandable. Secondly the weather turned, we played some nice stuff beforehand. Thirdly the Tigers line speed was impressive and didn’t let up after we scored the 4th and our intensity dropped.
While Faz had a few bad moments I’m happy to give him a break. He looked a bit knackered to me in the second half after the mental toll of captaining England in a World Cup and the physical toll of playing that South Africa team with a short turnaround after Fiji, the a short turnaround for Argentina. On that point, I’m surprised at some of the subs- Earl and Faz off instead of Goode and Christie when we were all but home and dry.
Not sure sure on Daly, Theo and Billy but think they will all feature against falcons!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2023:11:05:20:59:42 by jimfitz12.
Tbh I expected a real statement performance given the strength of the team put out and whilst it was very good I think it missed that.
Having said that all the stuff re the players coming back, some fatigue etc is right and there were more than enough signs of great things to come.
Interesting jimfitz any news on Mawi? he didn't look good when he came off.
A good (funny) and bad moment I only caught on watching the game back. Farrell calling for a pass from Kata when behind him and getting it
they looked to have a little laugh about it afterwards.
Far less funny is it looked a lot like a Dan Kelly cheap shot knocks Mawi out in the lead up to Shillcocks try. Mawi part of the attempted tackle on Kata but another player completes it. Mawi is beyond the ball and Kelly drops onto him with his shoulder/elbow looking to make contact. When he came off the issue didn't seem to be head but he lay so still for a good couple of minutes. Not good.
Quote:The Bard
And also on what the ref allows. Yesterday Hamish Smailes made competing in the lineout a no-go zone.
Don't get me started. In the Bath match Hamish allowed them to waste upwards of 30 seconds huddling at each line-out, yet gave Exeter the hurry up and threat of being penalised on one of the first line-outs yesterday. Consisitency.....bah!!
Successful hills are here to stay
Everything must be this way
Gentle streets where people play
Welcome to the Soft Parade
🌻🌻🌻
