Build on the Buzz: Wasps v Bath
Rokodoguni: sharp
By P G Tips
October 30 2019
Bath will want to harness the buzz of last week’s victory when they visit Wasps on Saturday. The character and tenacity that turned the team’s fortunes from one derby to the next are just the start. Now they will be looking for a complete performance and the first away win of the season. Winless Wasps sit only a point off the bottom courtesy of a losing bonus point. They seem highly vulnerable, but will be desperate for a first win of their own. Will they react with venom when their nest is poked?
Wasps have started poorly, but in theory at least, should be doing better. They have only two World Cup absentees, a clutch of exciting backs and enviable riches at loose forward. Dai Young, once thought a likely successor to Warren Gatland as Wales coach, has an eminent Lions playing pedigree. As a coach he fashioned packs as hard nosed as his own reputation and took Wasps to the Premiership Final in 2017, playing a mix of the exciting and pragmatic reminiscent of Wasps’ glory days at the beginning of the millennium. Now though, there are dark mutterings about his performance and future.
The vultures may not be circling just yet, but Young and his squad will not want their season to slump further. Which is why they should be far more dangerous than results suggest. After last Friday, Bath will need no reminding of the defiance a wounded beast can summon. A swarming assault can be expected.
So who are the hosts danger men? Their props made Gloucester struggle in the scrum last week, drawing several penalties. Gaskell will hope to rule the lineout, probably with help from Matthews, while Shields, Johnson and Carr will threaten on the carry and at the breakdown. Jack Willis though could be missing with a knee problem and Thomas Young remains on the long-term injury list. Behind the scrum, Dan Robson is also struggling with a knee injury and may not make it. A midfield chosen from Gopperth (who may be back to fitness), Sopoaga, De Jong and Fekitoa, should bring control, guile and pace to the attack. However it is the less celebrated Kibirige and Watson who have spearheaded the running threat recently.
Bath have definitely lost Clark who has had surgery on the hamstring he damaged at Ashton Gate. Dunn and Chudley should be fit, but there is as yet no news on Faletau. The selection is likely to be much the same as against Exeter, although I personally hope that Chris Cook’s speed of pass and thought last week is rewarded with a start.
So what should be the approach? First of all, Bath need the win for momentum. That means drawing Wasps sting: dominating possession and territory, forcing mistakes from their opponents to build pressure and scores. If Bath scrummage hard as they did against Chiefs there will be opportunities to kick for goal or launch their lineout drives. Wasps’ own lineout can be pressured: Gaskell is susceptible to wind up and Bath’s jumpers must contest the throw to make it “mission impossible” for Tom Cruse or Tommy Taylor the throwers.
With light rain and a gentle breeze expected on Saturday, an accurate kicking game will be needed but Bath also showed themselves capable of some decent handling in last week’s poor conditions. Hopefully they will find ways to work the ball wide to Brew and Rokodoguni as they did to Levi Davis in some of the PRC games.
A lot of Bath’s strike power will be at work earlier in the day in Yokohama, but Rokodoguni looked sharp ball in hand last Friday as did Brew on occasion. Mercer and the tight forwards can play their part too-especially at close quarters. Bath have had the better of the last few encounters between the teams- 3 wins and a draw from their meetings last season. If they are to improve on last year’s poor away record, the Ricoh where they gained their most convincing 2019 Premiership win on the road would be a good place to start. It is time to take the buzz up another notch and deliver a few stings themselves.
Possible Teams:
Bath:
Obano, Dunn, Stuart, Ewels (C), Stooke, Williams, Ellis, Mercer.
Cook, Priestland. Brew, Roberts, Wright, Rokodoguni. Homer.
Replacements: Boyce, Batty, Judge, McNally, Bayliss. Chudley, Burns, Hamer –Webb.
Wasps:
Zhvania, Cruse, Brookes, Gaskell, Matthews, Shields, Carr, Vailanu. Robson, Sopoaga. Bassett, de Jonge, Fekitoa, Kibirige. Watson.
Replacements: Taylor, Harris, Toomaga-Allen, Rowlands, Johnson. Wolstenholme, Umaga, Miller.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2019:11:06:11:09:02 by P G Tips.
I see Ant Watson is hinting at Wasps that they should let Marcus fly out to Japan, like Curry. Top work Ant - a win-win situation for Bath!

While I was still on the buzz"

... IMHO, of course.
Now in Honolulu
Apprehensive but hopeful so long as we don't regress to the Ashton Gate performance
BATH RUGBY TEAM TO FACE WASPS
15. Freddie Burns
14. Semesa Rokoduguni
13. Max Wright
12. Jamie Roberts
11. Aled Brew
10. Rhys Priestland
9. Chris Cook
1. Lewis Boyce
2. Jack Walker
3. Will Stuart
4. Elliott Stooke
5. Charlie Ewels
6. Mike Williams
7. Josh Bayliss
8. Zach Mercer
Replacements
16. Tom Dunn
17. Beno Obano
18. Henry Thomas
19. Josh McNally
20. Tom Ellis
21. Ollie Fox
22. Alex Davies
23. Gabriel Hamer-Webb
P G Tips
Jaco Coetzee: my adopted Player, 2023-24.
Pleasing to see the strength in depth in the forwards, with the subs bench groaning with power. Great to see Thomas back. The backs are a bit cobbled together, but with Cook, Priestland and Burns on the field, I'd suggest we kick the leather off it and try and grind out a valuable away win. Wasps have Gopperth back, mind, so won't be easy.
Add our World Cup stars, especially the backs, to that pack and we've got a very good looking XXIII. A win tomorrow would send us into a vital home game next week in fine fettle.
15 Matteo Minozzi
14 Zach Kibirige
13 Malakai Fekitoa
12 Jimmy Gopperth
11 Paolo Odogwu
10 Lima Sopoaga
9 Dan Robson (c)
1 Zurabi Zhvania
2 Tommy Taylor
3 Kieran Brookes
4 James Gaskell
5 Will Rowlands
6 Brad Shields
7 Nizaam Carr
8 Sione Vailanu
Replacements 16 Tom Cruse, 17 Ben Harris, 18 Jeff Toomaga-Allen, 19 Thibaud Flament, 20 Ash Johnson, 21 Sam Wolstenholme, 22 Billy Searle, 23 Michael Le Bourgeois
“This machine kills fascists”
Woody Guthrie's guitar.
Good to see Henry Thomas back. Is Batty injured or just 3rd choice?
COYB!
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:BathMatt53
Given the limited numbers of backs, its not great timing for Levi Davis to be away with the X-Factor, he would be getting some valuable game time otherwise - potentially his only opportunities this year with the cavalry on their way back soon?
COYB!
Levi Davis needs to decide whether he wants to be a rugby player or not.
One player who deserves a bit of a mention is Jack Walker, who has started to look like the player we hoped he'd be.
Quote:Any rugby player can be out of a job any week with a career ending injury. I think it's great to encourage them to have back-up careers or to be working towards an after rugby career. Or maybe he just wants a break from the awful coaching setup.OutsideBathQuote:BathMatt53
Given the limited numbers of backs, its not great timing for Levi Davis to be away with the X-Factor, he would be getting some valuable game time otherwise - potentially his only opportunities this year with the cavalry on their way back soon?
COYB!
Levi Davis needs to decide whether he wants to be a rugby player or not.
Quote:hemingtonQuote:Any rugby player can be out of a job any week with a career ending injury. I think it's great to encourage them to have back-up careers or to be working towards an after rugby career. Or maybe he just wants a break from the awful coaching setup.OutsideBathQuote:BathMatt53
Given the limited numbers of backs, its not great timing for Levi Davis to be away with the X-Factor, he would be getting some valuable game time otherwise - potentially his only opportunities this year with the cavalry on their way back soon?
COYB!
Levi Davis needs to decide whether he wants to be a rugby player or not.
Having a back up career is entirely sensible and the club should encourage this, but to go missing when we need him suggests he's not 100% committed to rugby.
However when you look at Bath's 9/10/12 it unlikely we need wingers anyway, total contrast to the excellent looking Wasps 9/10/12.
Asst Refs: JP Doyle & Paul Dix
TMO: Geoff Warren
Citing Officer: Paul Hull
Their loss is our gain.
J

Stuart
Former ed.
Commentator advised 8 Bath penalties in first half
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019:11:02:15:50:46 by abendanon-anon-anon.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:Yeah, a bit POd with this as well. I might fire up a Unibet account instead.Optimist
Cheers Stu - that prompted me to log on to Bet365,. Only joined to be able to livestream games and now it appears they dont any more. Still, I discovered I had 20 credit which Id forgotten. Might have a flutter on next England coach.
Thats 3 prem games and no backs tries despite seeming parity up front - the England boys cant come back fast enough IMO.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Sickening to lose the LBP
Quote:22Dropout
30-22 final score. Off for a few beers to drown the double sorrow.
Thanks for the updates - not good, only need Lewis bumped off the track to make it a poor weekend unlike the last !

Adopted Player 2018/19 Ross Batty
Adopted Player 2019/20 Jack Davies
Adopted Player 2020/21 Cam Redpath
Adopted Player 2021/22 Darren Atkins
Adopted Player 2022/23 Gabriel Hamer-Webb
Adopted Player 2023/24 Tom Carr-Smith
Adopted Player 2024/25 Max Ojomoh
"AN OUNCE OF ACTION IS WORTH A TON OF THEORY"
FRIEDRICH ENGELS
Quote:ken_jnr
I am about to leave the ground and I was happy to take the LBP. The onfield leadership to realise we have no attacking threat for 79 minutes was utterly pathetic. We have a pack to win a tight game and a plan to make sure it isnt tight.
Dont worry itll all be fixed in next weeks training
. Who have we got next week ? Oh dear 
Adopted Player 2018/19 Ross Batty
Adopted Player 2019/20 Jack Davies
Adopted Player 2020/21 Cam Redpath
Adopted Player 2021/22 Darren Atkins
Adopted Player 2022/23 Gabriel Hamer-Webb
Adopted Player 2023/24 Tom Carr-Smith
Adopted Player 2024/25 Max Ojomoh
"AN OUNCE OF ACTION IS WORTH A TON OF THEORY"
FRIEDRICH ENGELS
Another example of lack of our composure - With a LBP in the bag we try and create the miracle play and end up giving away a penalty and coming away with nothing.
Niaive to say the least the difference between challengers and clubs fighting at the base of the league, at least come away with something!!!!
I hope the returning cavalry and Hats can change things. Wasps were there for the taking today, our lack of attack given our platform is a real concern..
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019:11:02:17:35:26 by Ali1969.
Quote:Supermoto
When is it not "too soon" to panic?!
If we are in the bottom three at Xmas ?
Adopted Player 2018/19 Ross Batty
Adopted Player 2019/20 Jack Davies
Adopted Player 2020/21 Cam Redpath
Adopted Player 2021/22 Darren Atkins
Adopted Player 2022/23 Gabriel Hamer-Webb
Adopted Player 2023/24 Tom Carr-Smith
Adopted Player 2024/25 Max Ojomoh
"AN OUNCE OF ACTION IS WORTH A TON OF THEORY"
FRIEDRICH ENGELS
Quote:Ali1969
Another example of lack of our composure - With a LBP in the bag we try and create the miracle play and end up giving away a penalty and coming away with nothing.
Niaive to say the least..
I would be absolutely fing fuming if a team I played for, coached or supported booted the ball off the pitch while in possession and within a score for the sake of 1 league point - especially when we actually had that point as well as the ball.
Sorry guys, the pair have to go. Every respect for Hatley but he is going to have to shore up the forwards, sort out the defence and instigate an attack. No pressure there then. Or possibly he may stay in Japan on the saki.
What were we doing try to play from our own half when a losing bonus point was there for the taking. Very poor decision and woeful on field leadership. Not unusual for Bath and a continuing thread......
Ah well. Did people see what Irish nearly achieved at Saracens? They got closer than we have done in years.
10th is looking over ambitious.
Adopted player 2020/21 Beno 'the Transformer' Obano
Adopted player 2019/20 Jonathan 'JJ' Joseph.The Jink Joseph.
Adopted player 2018/19 Adopted player 2018/19 Semesa 'The Rock' Rokoduguni
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019:11:02:18:23:49 by Bathovalballer.
Quote:Bathovalballer
Well Mr Hooper bottom of the table and still no attack to speak of. Who is this bloke Dempsey? What does he do apart from fill up the soap dispensers at the Spa?
Sorry guys, the pair have to go. Every respect for Hatley but he is going to have to shore up the forwards, sort out the defence and instigate an attack. No pressure there then. Or possibly he may stay in Japan on the saki.
What were we doing try to play from our own half when a losing bonus point was there for the taking. Very poor decision and woeful on field leadership. Not unusual for Bath and a continuing thread......
Ah well. Did people see what Irish nearly achieved at Saracens? They got closer than we have done in years.
10th is looking over ambitious.
Curious where you watched the game BoB?
It was awful. Pointless listing how we gave away the bonus point in the last play by trying to run out of our try line. Or couldnt control the ball a few seconds before half time before penalty for holding on and try to Wasps right on HT.
Frankly a good thing were bottom. Hopefully the catalyst for a compete overhaul of this shambles of a club, on and off the field. Fed up with this nonsense.
Quote:ballsout
I was there. Free tickets from a mate.
It was awful. Pointless listing how we gave away the bonus point in the last play by trying to run out of our try line. Or couldnt control the ball a few seconds before half time before penalty for holding on and try to Wasps right on HT.
Frankly a good thing were bottom. Hopefully the catalyst for a compete overhaul of this shambles of a club, on and off the field. Fed up with this nonsense.
If you had that power would you wait for the RWC players to return first and see what Hoops (or potentially a new HC) can do with them?
Quote:B4thB4ckQuote:ballsout
I was there. Free tickets from a mate.
It was awful. Pointless listing how we gave away the bonus point in the last play by trying to run out of our try line. Or couldnt control the ball a few seconds before half time before penalty for holding on and try to Wasps right on HT.
Frankly a good thing were bottom. Hopefully the catalyst for a compete overhaul of this shambles of a club, on and off the field. Fed up with this nonsense.
If you had that power would you wait for the RWC players to return first and see what Hoops (or potentially a new HC) can do with them?
They havent helped in years so Im not sure what our out of their depth coaches can do. Genuinely dont care about results for the rest of the season, in fact finishing 11th or 12th will be better in the long run. The club cant go on like this.
Quote:ballsoutQuote:B4thB4ckQuote:ballsout
I was there. Free tickets from a mate.
It was awful. Pointless listing how we gave away the bonus point in the last play by trying to run out of our try line. Or couldnt control the ball a few seconds before half time before penalty for holding on and try to Wasps right on HT.
Frankly a good thing were bottom. Hopefully the catalyst for a compete overhaul of this shambles of a club, on and off the field. Fed up with this nonsense.
If you had that power would you wait for the RWC players to return first and see what Hoops (or potentially a new HC) can do with them?
They havent helped in years so Im not sure what our out of their depth coaches can do. Genuinely dont care about results for the rest of the season, in fact finishing 11th or 12th will be better in the long run. The club cant go on like this.
I understand but the question was about timing, when do you rip up the current plan. Too soon I would say.
Quote:B4thB4ckQuote:ballsoutQuote:B4thB4ckQuote:ballsout
I was there. Free tickets from a mate.
It was awful. Pointless listing how we gave away the bonus point in the last play by trying to run out of our try line. Or couldnt control the ball a few seconds before half time before penalty for holding on and try to Wasps right on HT.
Frankly a good thing were bottom. Hopefully the catalyst for a compete overhaul of this shambles of a club, on and off the field. Fed up with this nonsense.
If you had that power would you wait for the RWC players to return first and see what Hoops (or potentially a new HC) can do with them?
They havent helped in years so Im not sure what our out of their depth coaches can do. Genuinely dont care about results for the rest of the season, in fact finishing 11th or 12th will be better in the long run. The club cant go on like this.
I understand but the question was about timing, when do you rip up the current plan. Too soon I would say.
For appearances sake its too soon to do it now. But its going to be done eventually. Has to. For the sake of this club.
I'll not repeat what I said last week in response to our resident moaner because it is part of forum rules not to repeat the same opinion week after week. Suffice it to say that coaches and players can't coach and be coached if they are 6000 miles away. Everyone needs to be in the same country at least.
If the club start scratching around for losing bonus points at the expense of the chance for a result I would be very disappointed. 80th minute is where defences are at their most tired no harm in going for it.

Quote:Trawling
FFS stop asking for the umpteenth reboot. You can't invent a culture, you have to build it.
Funny, Bristol are managing ok. Theyll leave us in the dust like Exeter have in a year or two, if they havent already.
Talk to any ex player and theyll tell you how much of an utter shambles the club is. And its not bitterness, they left BECAUSE its in such a sorry state. Nobody has a good word to say.
Quote:Bath Supporter Jack
I bet we beat the team we are up against next week!
Aw bless.
Quote:Trawling
Well, Bristol are on their 4th? attempt to establish themselves in the Premiership. I didn't hear too many people lauding their previous efforts. They also spent a year playing much less demanding rugby in the Championship getting it right. Finally what do you mean by culture in their case? If it's about running ball from everywhere, I think you would have found lots of their own fans complaining of naivety last year and asking for a re-think: if you mean splashing big cash to get people in, that's ironically easier if you are under the cap in the first place; if you mean rebuilding your stadium, we know only too well the issues there and if you mean sticking a furry animal on the badge - good grief!
If you dont know what youre talking about, dont post. Ask Attwood about Bristols great club culture next time you see him.
And it doesnt matter what attempt theyre on, point is since Lam, theyre on the up. Their A side schooled ours last year on day 1 of the season and it set the tone.
Quote:ballsoutQuote:Trawling
FFS stop asking for the umpteenth reboot. You can't invent a culture, you have to build it.
Talk to any ex player and theyll tell you how much of an utter shambles the club is. And its not bitterness, they left BECAUSE its in such a sorry state. Nobody has a good word to say.
With respect most people who have left any organisation will criticise it and most currently in one will say things are fine.
We have had some good players re-sign contracts. I am not saying all is good, personally I think if the results were better the culture / off pitch criticisms would go away and that comes down to us needing a new HC. Hoops can take off the track suit with no face lost.
And if last season is what you want to focus on, they ended up 9th and we were 6th.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019:11:02:20:10:51 by Trawling.
For example, how to stop crabbing across the field, eventually losing ground and either dropping the ball or knocking it on. Ball retention in contact. To get Bath players running onto the ball, not taking it standing still. These failings have been there for seasons now, so no excuse for not getting them fixed like other sides seem able to do. Also, all this after the longest preseason on record.
Sorry guys Mr H and the 'attack'? coach have to go and now or our Prem. status will be under even greater threat by Christmas. Without Prem. status we will probably kiss goodbye to our desperately needed new stadium as well.
Adopted player 2020/21 Beno 'the Transformer' Obano
Adopted player 2019/20 Jonathan 'JJ' Joseph.The Jink Joseph.
Adopted player 2018/19 Adopted player 2018/19 Semesa 'The Rock' Rokoduguni
Of course if the yardstick is beating Exeter then they might decide to give Hooper more time. If that is unpalatable then blame Exeter for losing to us, they must be rubbish.
Adopted player 2020/21 Beno 'the Transformer' Obano
Adopted player 2019/20 Jonathan 'JJ' Joseph.The Jink Joseph.
Adopted player 2018/19 Adopted player 2018/19 Semesa 'The Rock' Rokoduguni
Quote:Bathovalballer
Mr H is only part of the problem. The main one is the man or persons who appointed him to that position for which he is hugely unqualified, especially without suitably qualified and experienced lieutenants to support him. It is palpably not entirely his fault.
Of course. If only we had an international forwards coach lined up to help out after the RWC..............?
There is a reason for this constant underperformance year after year and it isnt because were currently lacking a head coach in 2019/20.
Craig blunders by sticking his nose in. We lost Matson for that reason and he and Tarquin idiotically then appointed Hooper and Rock now. Theres plenty more issues but thats the top end problem.
Quote:ballsout
What positives are there to say about a club regularly filled with big name players, thats finished in the top 4 a grand total of 1 time in nine years?
There is a reason for this constant underperformance year after year and it isnt because were currently lacking a head coach in 2019/20.
Craig blunders by sticking his nose in. We lost Matson for that reason and he and Tarquin idiotically then appointed Hooper and Rock now. Theres plenty more issues but thats the top end problem.
This is the club we support, we have as supporters no real influence therefore I suggest all you can do as you are in such turmoil is to decide whether to support the club or not, ultimately that is all that is within your control. (To repeat we rely on Bruce financially to survive in the professional era like it or lump it!)
Opt I am sorry but that lost point might be the difference between Qualifying for Champions Cup, Playoffs or even relegation who knows but history has shown just how important bonus points are especially come the end of the season.
I am a pragmatist and yes if there was an even chance to win a game but when you are camped deep inside your own half really!!!

Quote:Bath Hammer
I have an excellent idea. Since BoB has such intricate...!
Cue hilarious post from BoB referencing Old Prostates, beer, spas, Spurrell, Cooch and Dawesy.
It might be boring but for those of us who witnessed our near demise until Elvis scored that try, and had to take on the pragmatism of the Connolly years, we did improve and started to win games regularly. Trouble is we have never consistently kicked on from there.
Adopted player 2020/21 Beno 'the Transformer' Obano
Adopted player 2019/20 Jonathan 'JJ' Joseph.The Jink Joseph.
Adopted player 2018/19 Adopted player 2018/19 Semesa 'The Rock' Rokoduguni
Quote:Bathovalballer
take on the pragmatism of the Connolly years,
Careful BOB! Connolly & his sidekick Foley got rid of Catt, Tindall, Balshaw, Lyle & Regan- many of whom came back to hurt us in the colours of their new clubs!
PG
What was more annoying more was our (typical and bizarrely longstanding) problem of not being able to hold on to or control the ball. We were in possession on half way with literally ten seconds to go till half-time, we should have slowed each carry down but no, lost the ball with time almost up. Scrum. Penalty to them. Kick to corner, try under the posts. Poor.
Still, credit where its due to Ollie Fox who, at short notice, was promoted from the bench to make his Premiership debut, and ended up playing the full 80 mins up against Robson whos an experienced and pretty classy operator at 9.
By no means perfect and things to work on but he didnt look out of his depth and will hopefully push Chudders and Cookie for more starts this season.
Adopted player 2020/21 Beno 'the Transformer' Obano
Adopted player 2019/20 Jonathan 'JJ' Joseph.The Jink Joseph.
Adopted player 2018/19 Adopted player 2018/19 Semesa 'The Rock' Rokoduguni
Had we not tried for the miracle win and kicked the ball out we would not be bottom of the Premiership this weekend. I know we need to show ambition but it was clearly not on. If we do continue to be at the wrong end of the table, we are going to need more pragmatism.
Quote:Ali1969
Shipwrecked I agree but it is the identification when the chance is in or not. You are quite right we have lost so many games at the death, often due to our error and not from the opposition creating, however we have all seen teams kick out the ball when they realise there is no chance of the miracle win and don't want to lose the LBP, this is down to leadership and on field decision making. Basically you know if things have been clicking but our confidence in these situations coupled with our backline would suggest leave with something.
Decent point I guess I'm 50:50 on this one, but I prefer a team ethic that says go for it. Wasps had a choice go for their own try bonus point or prevent us getting one. Pretty negative to go for the latter in my view I would hope if we were in the same situation we would go for the try bonus point. I prefer to be positive.

Quote:ken_jnr
For all the star names in the Wasps backline I thought they were going to be better but they still won and kept us neutered in attack for much of the game.
Wasps are pretty poor so far this year, that was their first win, which makes leaving with 0 points even worse.
Quote:Bristol Welsh
Poor coaching, poor planning, poor execution. It may be that over the season it doesn't matter, but then again, why take the chance?
So are you saying that is the Bristol way of approaching the game, safety first.
If so I suggest you talk to your coach, how many points have Bristol thrown away by running it from suicidal positions then?
Is that equally "Poor coaching, poor planning, poor execution?"
Nothing wrong in having a go! Ask Pat Lam.

[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:Ali1969
Shipwrecked totally with you I would always like to be positive, but given our fragility for me it was a no brainer. I have a feeling Wasps feel we may be scrapping it out with us for something and to deny us a point was worth more to them than getting an extra try bonus point.
Don't worry Ali, Sarries are going to be on minus points soon if BoB is right. Have faith, post WC the best is yet to come..........I hope!

[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:Long Term
we have as supporters no real influence therefore I suggest all you can do as you are in such turmoil is to decide whether to support the club or not
This is possibly the most sensible comment in this thread. It's clear from what we've seen to date this season that Hooper is guiding Bath towards the championship, so all we can do is decide whether to watch it happen or not.
Quote:OutsideBathQuote:Long Term
we have as supporters no real influence therefore I suggest all you can do as you are in such turmoil is to decide whether to support the club or not
This is possibly the most sensible comment in this thread. It's clear from what we've seen to date this season that Hooper is guiding Bath towards the championship, so all we can do is decide whether to watch it happen or not.
I will happily make a bet with you - 50 to the charity of the others choice at the end of the season. If Bath go down I donate to yours, if they stay up you donate to mine. Are you game?
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:BathMatt53Quote:OutsideBathQuote:Long Term
we have as supporters no real influence therefore I suggest all you can do as you are in such turmoil is to decide whether to support the club or not
This is possibly the most sensible comment in this thread. It's clear from what we've seen to date this season that Hooper is guiding Bath towards the championship, so all we can do is decide whether to watch it happen or not.
I will happily make a bet with you - 50 to the charity of the others choice at the end of the season. If Bath go down I donate to yours, if they stay up you donate to mine. Are you game?
I've already placed a 1k bet on it happening.
Quote:OutsideBathQuote:Long Term
we have as supporters no real influence therefore I suggest all you can do as you are in such turmoil is to decide whether to support the club or not
This is possibly the most sensible comment in this thread. It's clear from what we've seen to date this season that Hooper is guiding Bath towards the championship, so all we can do is decide whether to watch it happen or not.
For the umpteenth time, how can you criticise a coaching regime when it is not even in place, let alone had time to effect change? You do realise Hatley is not in place and our backs have been in Japan?
Time to criticise is when Hately has been in place for 4-6 games with a full set of backs.

Quote:shipwreckedQuote:OutsideBathQuote:Long Term
we have as supporters no real influence therefore I suggest all you can do as you are in such turmoil is to decide whether to support the club or not
This is possibly the most sensible comment in this thread. It's clear from what we've seen to date this season that Hooper is guiding Bath towards the championship, so all we can do is decide whether to watch it happen or not.
For the umpteenth time, how can you criticise a coaching regime when it is not even in place, let alone had time to effect change? You do realise Hatley is not in place and our backs have been in Japan?
Time to criticise is when Hately has been in place for 4-6 games with a full set of backs.
I respect Hatley a lot and welcome his return, but he's not the messiah. Is he going to fix the attack and poor decision making as well? So far only Charteris is showing any competence.
We are in desperate need of a bit of confidence but I don't see a lack of effort, misdirected effort perhaps.

If Hooper, Charteris and Hately can't make those players work the I would call for a change too.
I would still like to see a defence coach though.

Quote:ballsout
People are putting a lot of faith in players returning to turn things around. Hopefully due to their individual one-off talents, rather than how they fit into a broken system. We've had these players for years and they haven't made us top 4 contenders. It's not about the individuals or the name on the team sheet.
I agree with your point but it has to be a positive to some degree. Those involved in the final from both sides will come back from an elite level with good habits. If Flo assumes his international career is nearly over at 34 why would he not work well back at Bath to help form the new coaching setup? The only thing preventing that would be a bad culture blocking such positive contributions.
The weather also has not been kind so far, but once it dries up I hope the team at least try to play a more expansive game. Not sure if it is a reaction to watching some good rugby at the WC but so far I have been completely underwhelmed by the premiership.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
The problem with JR and RP is they have both lost a lot of pace.

Quote:Bath Supporter Jack
As they say if RP and JR are the answer.........we are asking the wrong question!
wrong question or wrong year.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]

Quote:BathMatt53
Im not sure that anyone has said that RP cant kick. He is a very good tactical kicker. Whether RP and JR get a back line moving (and make the most of the England returnees) is the concern.
Then maybe we should play to his strengths. A 9 with a fast pass to give him time (I thought Ollie Fox did well) and kick for position. Then use the forwards to strangle the oppo into a mistake. Take the 3. Repeat. Sound familiar at all? SA, Sarries, Exeter, Leicester in their pomp...
Dull? - yes, boring? - unquestionably, winning strategy? - recent evidence strongly suggests so.
... IMHO, of course.
Now in Honolulu
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:BathMatt53
Best get the p45s sorted for the returning England backs then...oh and can I have a refund on my season ticket?!
Trouble is, playing outside RP and JR, they are not going to get the ball in any space. In that case, it doesn't matter how good you are or how fast your feet, gravity always wins.
... IMHO, of course.
Now in Honolulu
On paper, our first choice backline is top class, and combining JR and JJ makes sense to me. The question for me, is JR still up to it and can Dempsey coach the best out of them? On the evidence of this season, JR isn't going to let anyone down but Dempsey's influence is still up for debate. If by the season end he hasn't got some tries out of our backs then he's not up to it.
Quote:hemington
Dempsey didn't seem to have much trouble getting tries when coaching at Leinster.
Which is why it is all the more confusing / annoying.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Look how Reinach holds the defense with his speed and interceptions, (he is out of contract with Saints soon, though expected to go to Montpellier). We have to be see how the returnees get on and get the pack to establish their promised dominance.
I also think that Underhill will change the dynamic for the pack, if he can catch their backs behind the gain line and propel them backwards as he did in Japan that would open up the game for Roko. Joe C, Rory, JJ and Watson.
This is where we get to find out if Hooper's team can put the bits of the puzzle together. If as you say things haven't changed on the try front despite having our key players back then we have a big problem!

Having said the above, I have dreams where Cipriani is wearing our 10 jersey...
Quote:dr.bath1865
I agree, to an extent, but Priestland is an international 10 who has played with Roberts for many years. They could have me playing 9 and they should still be able to get something out of the internationals outside them. I still wonder whether Cook might be the one who steps up and delivers on his promise, although I wouldn't be willing to bet on it.
Having said the above, I have dreams where Cipriani is wearing our 10 jersey...
...but Priestland was an international 10 who has played with Roberts for many years.... and they had the likes of Rhys Webb at 9 threatening round the fringes, you are right though in his international career he did 'have a go'. Haven't seen it for a wile at the Rec.


Quote:ballsout
I bet London Irish or Bristol would get more out of Chudley-Priestland-Roberts than we do.
Possibly one of them at any one time. Not sure about all 3 together.
I wonder if other clubs could get more out of Cook, Burns, Willison - individually and/or in combination - than we have managed. I would hope so - because we've squeezed the square root of f-all out of what most people would regard as three decent talents.
Quote:OptimistQuote:ballsout
I bet London Irish or Bristol would get more out of Chudley-Priestland-Roberts than we do.
Possibly one of them at any one time. Not sure about all 3 together.
I wonder if other clubs could get more out of Cook, Burns, Willison - individually and/or in combination - than we have managed. I would hope so - because we've squeezed the square root of f-all out of what most people would regard as three decent talents.
You would be lucky to get either of the combinations to play 3-4 games in a row due to injuries/concussion! Younger players are a little less susceptible to injury.
Even Willison is 31.

Quote:OptimistQuote:ballsout
I bet London Irish or Bristol would get more out of Chudley-Priestland-Roberts than we do.
Possibly one of them at any one time. Not sure about all 3 together.
I wonder if other clubs could get more out of Cook, Burns, Willison - individually and/or in combination - than we have managed. I would hope so - because we've squeezed the square root of f-all out of what most people would regard as three decent talents.
Pretty much any other club would get more out of all our players than we do, that much has been obvious for years. My point was in relation to people saying we need a big name 9, 10 and 12. What for? So they can underperform like everyone else at Bath?
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:ballsout
Pretty much any other club would get more out of all our players than we do, that much has been obvious for years. My point was in relation to people saying we need a big name 9, 10 and 12. What for? So they can underperform like everyone else at Bath?
If any other club would get more out of any player how come Bath had so many players at the world cup? If what you say is true then they wouldn't have been playing well enough to even be considered.
Adopted player 2019/20 Will Chudley. Weird split household co-parented
player 2020 Josh Matavesi
Quote:ballsoutQuote:OptimistQuote:ballsout
I bet London Irish or Bristol would get more out of Chudley-Priestland-Roberts than we do.
Possibly one of them at any one time. Not sure about all 3 together.
I wonder if other clubs could get more out of Cook, Burns, Willison - individually and/or in combination - than we have managed. I would hope so - because we've squeezed the square root of f-all out of what most people would regard as three decent talents.
Pretty much any other club would get more out of all our players than we do, that much has been obvious for years. My point was in relation to people saying we need a big name 9, 10 and 12. What for? So they can underperform like everyone else at Bath?
We don't need a big name, but we do need a younger name at 10. RP and JR learnt their trade early Gatland, 10's like Cips and George Ford play a flatter, faster game. Its incredibly hard to relearn the 10 position if your instinct is to play deeper and let your 12 smash it up.

Adopted player 2020/21 Beno 'the Transformer' Obano
Adopted player 2019/20 Jonathan 'JJ' Joseph.The Jink Joseph.
Adopted player 2018/19 Adopted player 2018/19 Semesa 'The Rock' Rokoduguni
Quote:ballsoutQuote:Bath Supporter Jack
I bet we beat the team we are up against next week!
Aw bless.
Clearly Ballsout the Bath Team, the crowd at the Rec.....me included, were indeed blessed.
You on the other hand are obviously not as you seem to have gone missing

Quote:Bath Supporter JackQuote:ballsoutQuote:Bath Supporter Jack
I bet we beat the team we are up against next week!
Aw bless.
Clearly Ballsout the Bath Team, the crowd at the Rec.....me included, were indeed blessed.
You on the other hand are obviously not as you seem to have gone missing
Take a bow BFJ, great call
Be nice if they went permanently MIA.
