Get Up and Go Again...
By Devonport Boy
October 4 2023
I’m told that this phrase has been one of the cornerstones of pre-season training at Farleigh this year, aimed at embedding momentum and dynamism in all aspects of the Bath game. There was certainly plenty of that on display against Saints last Saturday from a strong Bath team running out for the first time together. Expectations were high after a brilliant first half although ultimately it turned out to be “frustration at Franklin’s” as Northampton staged a second half comeback to win by one point. Plenty for the defence coaches to work on, but similarly there’s a lot to look forward to especially when those currently playing in France come back into the mix.
So, it’s time to get up and go again for next weekend, but with a friendly scheduled for Friday evening against Edinburgh at the Hive stadium and Exeter coming to the Rec for the final round of the Premiership Cup pool games, who’s going where? Looking at the opposition, Edinburgh have played one friendly game against Connacht last week. They fielded a strong team in the first half to lead Connacht 19-7 at the break but wholesale changes in the second half lead to a 19-45 defeat. Exeter on the other hand ran out 47-10 winners at Sandy Park against London Scottish.
It says something for the work of the coaches and the strength and conditioning teams in pre-season that we are able to field two match fit squads in one weekend. I also think we can assume that JvG has done his analysis during the Premiership Cup games and knows pretty much who will be in the mix for selection for the Newcastle game on 14th October. With that in mind, I think one squad will be based on the team that played against Saints, although there may be some changes with the likes of Alfie Barbeary, Ruaridh McConnochie, and Josh McNally yet to make an appearance this season. I may be completely wrong, but I think the other squad will look very much like the one that started the Premiership Cup off with a win against the Pirates, albeit with a few more experienced players in some positions.
As a supporter we always want to see the strongest possible Bath team run out at the Rec and the indications are that we’re going to get what we would like with a strong team running out against Exeter and Andy Robinson taking a more youthful squad up to Edinburgh. On balance I think that’s right – we need to build up the momentum before Newcastle come to town next week.
I know a lot of us were sceptical about the value of the Premiership Cup format, but on the whole I think it’s worked. On one level it’s provided a great opportunity for younger players to showcase their talents, but you could also regard it as a structured pre-season competition which must have given JvG and his coaching team a good insight into how the playing strategies are developing and what changes need to be made. I’ve enjoyed watching our developing players and the Championship teams make this a strongly contested competition, although it never crossed my mind that the game against Jersey might be the last time we saw them as a team. We all feel for them and hope that a solution will be found both for them and for Championship rugby as a whole. We need them.
So a big weekend coming up. The boys are going to get up and go again and both these games will be hard, so we need to do the same, especially at the Rec.
COME ON YOU BATH.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2023:10:09:17:14:19 by CoochieCoo.
Saturday, 2.00
Bath Rugby XV:
15 Tom de Glanville
14 Joe Cokanasiga
13 Max Ojomoh
12 Will Butt
11 Will Muir
10 Piers Francis
09 Louis Schreuder
1 Juan Schoeman
2 Niall Annett
3 Johannes Jonker
4 Ted Hill
5 Charlie Ewels
6 Miles Reid (c)
7 Chris Cloete
8 Alfie Barbeary
Replacements: 16 Tom Dunn, 17 Beno Obano, 18 Thomas du Toit, 19 Fergus Lee-Warner, 20 Sam Underhill, 21 Ben Spencer, 22 Orlando Bailey, 23 Jaco Coetzee
Meanwhile, Ruaridh and Max are babysitting the kids up in Edinburgh (against a much stronger looking Embra side). With Sam Harris starting at FH, and Billy Sela is (I think) due to make his debut.
Things I don't like, are Francis at FH, and why we insist on a 6:2 bench, (especially egregious with the extra backrower in the 23 shirt).
Otherwise, great to see Alfie back, and to see Miles back in his proper shirt.
RAEBURN SHIELD
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2023:10:05:13:30:06 by Quel Carreleur.
Bath Rugby XV: 1 Arthur Cordwell, 2 Jasper Spandler, 3 Kieran Verden, 4 JJ Tonks, 5 Ewan Richards (c), 6 Ethan Staddon, 7 Thompson Cowan, 8 Arthur Green, 9 Tom Carr-Smith, 10 Sam Harris, 11 Ruaridh McConnochie, 12 Max Wright, 13 Louie Hennessey, 14 Gabe Goss, 15 Ciaran Donoghue
Replacements: 16 Max Pearce, 17 Mikey Summerfield, 18 Archie Griffin, 19 Mackenzie Graham, 20 Eddie Erksine, 21, Josh Dingley, 22 Abdul-Khalik Akenzua Al-Kareem, 23 Nahum Merigan, 24 Ieuan Davies, 25 George Worboys, 26 Will Parry, 27 Luke Graham, 28 Billy Sela
PG
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
2024/25 adoptee: Guy Pepper
adopted player, 24/25 Hame Faiva. 23/24 Ted Hill. 22/23 Cam Redpath. 21/22 Max Clark. 20/21 Henry Thomas. 19/20 Max Wright. 18/19 Cooper Vuna.
Quote:copester
Like both squads, only downside for me is Ted Hill in the Row. Hope he gets through it unscathed and not too brassed off. My low level experience of asking a back row to play lock never seemed to go down too well!
Not ideal is it.
All our tighthead locks sound injured- roux, mcnally and cuckson.
Fingers crossed roux going off sounded precautionary
No idea why mcnally hasn't featured yet.
Exeter Chiefs Team:
15. Josh Hodge
14. Immanuel Feyi-Waboso
13. Henry Slade
12. Joe Hawkins
11. Tommy Wyatt
10. Harvey Skinner
9. Tom Cairns
1. Scott Sio
2. Jack Yeandle ©
3. Ehren Painter
4. Rusi Tuima
5. Lewis Pearson
6. Ethan Roots
7. Jacques Vermeulen
8. Greg Fisilau
Replacements:
16. Max Norey
17. Billy Keast
18. Josh Iosefa-Scott
19. Matt Postlethwaite
20. Aidon Davis
21. Niall Armstrong
22. Will Haydon-Wood
23. Tom Hendrickson
Quote:copester
Like both squads, only downside for me is Ted Hill in the Row.
Hmm, I thought FLW could play 2nd row? Seems odd to me.
Unfotunate to get injuries so early in a position we are borderline light already
17 Beno Obano, Tom Dunn, 18 Thomas du Toit, 19 Fergus Lee-Warner, 5 Charlie Ewels, 4 Ted Hill , 20 Sam Underhill, 23 Jaco Coetzee.
hopefully a good day tomorrow.
Quote:Yellow Hammer
This would make a good finishing 8.
17 Beno Obano, Tom Dunn, 18 Thomas du Toit, 19 Fergus Lee-Warner, 5 Charlie Ewels, 4 Ted Hill , 20 Sam Underhill, 23 Jaco Coetzee.
hopefully a good day tomorrow.
Hope so too but I'll be most happy if our returning players get some valuable match conditioning time and we avoided the injuries.
Second half was almost a completely new team (up to #28) and with a few more ball carriers the equal of Edinburgh it was more even, even with Edinburgh having largely the same team for 60 mins bar the front 3 - who had overpowered Bath in the maul and scrum. Second half score was 5-5. I liked the young 10 (who moved to RW in the second half) He had no front foot ball in the first half but wanted to play rather than kick which was a pleasant change to the eye. Second half the ruck caterpillars reappeared and the game tailed off with all the substitutions. Hope the coaches learned something.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Good to heat Sam Harris was brave in his approach- great prospect.
Anyone stand out second half in terms of the improved ball carrying?
We were always going to struggle at set piece with that extremely youthful pack
Quote:nick holder
looking ok so far, 17/0 after 25 mins
That's a surprisingly good start. Any insights into what is going so well?
Pitch is really cutting up.
37 mins gone
Half time
Quote:dcsh
So if the Jersey matches get removed, as was the case last season when clubs went bust, then it looks like we might qualify.
Really? How come? Exeter haven't lost a game, apart from today, have they?
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2023:10:07:17:46:22 by gaz59.
Quote:gaz59Quote:dcsh
So if the Jersey matches get removed, as was the case last season when clubs went bust, then it looks like we might qualify.
Really? How come? Exeter haven't lost a game, apart from today, have they?
And if you remove Jersey, we only lost to Saints - and we got two bonus points from it, and we got try bonus points in all the other games.
Quote:gaz59Quote:dcsh
So if the Jersey matches get removed, as was the case last season when clubs went bust, then it looks like we might qualify.
Really? How come? Exeter haven't lost a game, apart from today, have they?
And we’ve only lost one if the Jersey game is ignored. Exeter got 5 points against Jersey so if you remove those both teams are W3L1 and we’ve got more bonus points.
Quote:Indeed I believe that Exeter would have 15 points, while we would have 17, in this scenario.9215Quote:gaz59Quote:dcsh
So if the Jersey matches get removed, as was the case last season when clubs went bust, then it looks like we might qualify.
Really? How come? Exeter haven't lost a game, apart from today, have they?
And we’ve only lost one if the Jersey game is ignored. Exeter got 5 points against Jersey so if you remove those both teams are W3L1 and we’ve got more bonus points.

Quote:CoochieCoo
The pitch was cutting up badly and the groundsmen earned their wings sorting out the divots! Especially this one
The state of the pitch was a real concern, grass has just not bedded in. Can we be penalised for providing a poor quality playing surface? Because that can't be up to premiership standard.
Ted Hill worthy of motm, but for me the most exciting thing was watching Alfie Barbeary carry strongly. He has the potential to make a big difference.
Quote:CoochieCoo
The pitch was cutting up badly and the groundsmen earned their wings sorting out the divots! Especially this one
I love that

If we can keep fit beno, stuart/tdt, alfie/coetzee, spencer , russell for rhe majority of the season I would see it as being v achievable
[video.premiershiprugby.com]
RAEBURN SHIELD
It wasn't a perfect performance by any means but the progress in 12 months is obvious and the players are smiling and full of confidence. I think we will be one of the few teams to be stronger this year than last and Top 4 isn't unrealistic.
Positives from me yesterday was the fact we played our best rugby in the First Half before some bigger names came on - there is decent depth in the squad in most areas. Super Ted Hill was super. Tom DG is looking in very good form - I hope the knock at the end isn't serious. The phase play was good too, underpinned by improved handling in contact. Our penalty count also wasn't totally absurd.
Exeter were poor it has to be said, certainly for the first hour but we did the job in hand and scoring at the end with 14 on the pitch was pleasing.
Tougher and more meaningful games to come but things aren't looking bad at all - apart from the pitch which looks like my wife's allotment.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2023:10:08:08:16:32 by Rokobilly.
Only concern reported by my daughter, who was there, was TdG who went off after a heavy blow, and MAY be a HIA issue.....
Assume coetzee for barbeary was tactical?
Garvey said we were v good value got the win and should have been more..... and he has been fairly critical of us last few games.
He loved the indication of good culture/mindset when with the clock in the red we still went after their scrum and won a pen.
As we were down to 14 he had to stay on!
Quote:Maeght
Sam Underhill has been called up to England's World Cup squad as cover on Willis, so hopefully Cloete is ok.
Fingers crossed.
Even without underhill and cloete I guess we could probably name a backrow of hill/reid/barbeary with coetzee on the bench. Crazy depth!
Quote:TdG don’t go off for an HIA, but not sure if that was because he was knocked out (and didn’t need one) or if it was a different injury. Hopefully he is OK as he seems to have been playing well.WasBBWBaaBaa
Any injuries yesterday?
Only concern reported by my daughter, who was there, was TdG who went off after a heavy blow, and MAY be a HIA issue.....
Quote:Rokobilly
Re Alfie replaced by Jaco - seemed tactical / pre-planned.
Quote:Maeght
hopefully Cloete is ok
JVG's comments at the end of the match seem to address both these points:
JVG: "You can’t ask for more. There was no expectation expect for him to get the ball in his hands. I thought he looked pretty well and I kept him on a bit longer than anticipated.
"Chris Cloete was tight at half time, that is why I brought him off for Sam Underhill, that meant Alfie played a bit longer. I thought he was very good."
Match Report
Quote:Maeght
Sam Underhill has been called up to England's World Cup squad as cover on Willis, so hopefully Cloete is ok.
Borthwick won't pick him for the Fiji match and then he'll be home along with Ollie
Spencers little kick to put the ball into Bath hands off a wayward pass from Barbeary at the base was class as was Muirs regathering and offload of the cross-field kick. Great first 40 in particular.
Interesting to see Chiefs come back into the game at the point I felt your bench would take the game away from them?
Quote:Looks like the administration of the cup have decided to let the Jersey results stand rather than last season’s approach, so Exeter top the group.dcshQuote:Indeed I believe that Exeter would have 15 points, while we would have 17, in this scenario.9215Quote:gaz59Quote:dcsh
So if the Jersey matches get removed, as was the case last season when clubs went bust, then it looks like we might qualify.
Really? How come? Exeter haven't lost a game, apart from today, have they?
And we’ve only lost one if the Jersey game is ignored. Exeter got 5 points against Jersey so if you remove those both teams are W3L1 and we’ve got more bonus points.
[www.premiershiprugby.com]
Really? How come? Exeter haven't lost a game, apart from today, have they?[/quote]
And we’ve only lost one if the Jersey game is ignored. Exeter got 5 points against Jersey so if you remove those both teams are W3L1 and we’ve got more bonus points.[/quote]
Indeed I believe that Exeter would have 15 points, while we would have 17, in this scenario.[/quote]
So meeting to confirm the allocation of points for unfulfilled fixtures, but not confirming what has been decided on fixtures involving Jersey Reds? Clear as mud.
