Bath vs Saracens - BACK TO THE REAL STUFF
Ted
By Bath Supporter Jack
March 17 2026
So, after the interlude of the Six Nations/PREM Cup, we get back to the Gallagher Premiership this Friday evening with a home match against Saracens.
We have watched the Six Nations, and some have enjoyed games much more than others! In particular Italy beating England, Scotland beating England (again!), and beating France but failing at the last hurdle against a recovering Ireland.
I was surprised to read in Tarquin Mcdonald’s season ticket renewal letter that Bath had more players in the Six Nations than any other Premiership Club. Bath also had several younger players in the U20 Six Nations. Coupled with some excellent performances by other young developing players in the PREM Cup there was evidence of real depth in the playing resources.
So, in the Premiership League, 10 games have been played and there are another 8 to go. The league looks like it has split into two, the top six Saints, Bath, Bristol, Leicester, Exeter and Saracens and the rest. The gap between Saracens in 6th with 32 points to Sale Sharks in 7th with 20 points is a seemingly insuperable 12 points.
As mentioned on the “preliminary” match day thread the next three matches are very important, mind you it seems like every game in this league is important! However, Saracens at home followed by Sale away in the Premiership followed by Saracens at home in the Last 16 of the Champions Cup are an important trio of matches as we have Saints, Bristol and Exeter away in the last six games!
In these next two rounds Leicester play Bristol and Saracens play Saints. So at least our competitors will also be taking chunks out of each other!
Our opponents, like us, have international players returning to the Club scene, and consequently some players will have to take a rest game. Including possibly Itoje, Daly, Earl, George and emerging Duncan Bell look alike (look up his try for Wales) Rhys Carre. The Saracens Preview still has them looking up, for a play-off place, “there is still all to play for but Sarries need to get something out of those next 2 games against the top 2: probably targeting The Showdown against Saints rather than Friday night at the Rec which is what comes up next”.
Many of the players will be raring to go and given JVG’s strict rotation and exclusion over the past four weeks virtually the whole squad must be fit and refreshed.
Friday night under the lights in dry but chilly weather, all to look forward to.
A possible team selection like this but I found this very difficult even excluding Spencer, Finn, Pepper, Underhill, Griffin, Hennessy, Cockanasiga, Butt, possibly injured Moloney and of course long-term injured Stuart and Coetzee.
1.Obano
2.Dunn
3.Sela
4.Roux
5.Ewells
6.Bayliss
7.Reid
8.Barbeary
9.TCS
10.Carreras
11.Muir
12.Ojomoh
13.Lawrence
14.Arundell
15.TdG
16.Frost
17.TdT
18.FVW
19.Hill
20.Richards
21.Green
22.BVDL
23.Redpath
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:24:08:34:03 by P G Tips.
Good write up. I peronally would start Hill - as others have suggested. I think this is just his sort of match.
PG
Quote:P G Tips
Thanks BSJ
Good write up. I peronally would start Hill - as others have suggested. I think this is just his sort of match.
PG
+1
... IMHO, of course.
Now in Honolulu
I told you it was difficult to choose!!
Quote:BathRob
Difficult to argue with that BSJ - although would you be tempted to go the other way round? Reed, Bayliss and Barbeary coming off the bench is wince-inducing if you’re a tired centre combo
I first read that as wine-inducing and thought "that's about right!"
Tdg
Big joe
Lawrence
Mojo
Muir
Santi
Tcs
Beno
Dunn
Sela
Roux
Ewels
Hill
Reid
Green
Bench: kepu, fvw, tdt, richards, bayliss, bvdl, redpath, alfie
Would have been tempted to put staddon in based on recent form but I am in a bigger mood about him going than alfie
Result feels a bit of a lottery with 2 very rusty teams ans us potentially resting our frontline halfbacks
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:OutsideBath
Personally I’m hoping we go as strong as we can as it’s a home game and do the resting for Sale next week.
I agree, I can see wholescale changes for Sale with Europe the week after.
adopted player, 24/25 Hame Faiva. 23/24 Ted Hill. 22/23 Cam Redpath. 21/22 Max Clark. 20/21 Henry Thomas. 19/20 Max Wright. 18/19 Cooper Vuna.
Quote:BathMatt53
I would play Arundell again given how well he did vs Sarries last time and how he is simply a point of difference at Prem level. Is Sela fit? (I would start TDT)
More than happy to see arundell, not sure at whose cost though.
No idea re sela- played in prem cup ? Last time we saw him?
Kind of makes sense to rest him vs Bedford with tdt rusty (does that man rust!?) and griffin needing to rest in next 3 games I assume!? Cotton wool treatment hopefully
Quote:copesterQuote:OutsideBath
Personally I’m hoping we go as strong as we can as it’s a home game and do the resting for Sale next week.
I agree, I can see wholescale changes for Sale with Europe the week after.
I would mix and match through the next 3 fixtures personally.
Some of that will be forced on us anyway.
Wouldn't be starting loads against sale away who we wan t to start against sarries in last 16 as only 6 day turnaround. Wouldn't have any qualms about a few starting both and loading the bench though.
Not because I think we can win it this year (not dismising that possibility though), but because we can't win it next year, or the year after, until we've banked experience of the last 8/last 4.
Pick the strongest team for last 16
Can't wait, should be a great game!
Quote:ShortyinBurnham
Have just seen that McCall has confirmed that Itoje and George will definitely not play on Friday. He didn't mention any of the other returning Internationals though.
Can't wait, should be a great game!
Posted in other thread but this from The Times implies Earl will be involved given it's a very different message to the one about George and Itoje:
"On Earl, who played 369 of 400 possible Six Nations minutes, McCall said: “He obviously had a great tournament. He’s feeling really good about his rugby. He’s one of the ones who shone all the way through. He’s in the building this week but he will get a week off in the next three weeks.”
For that reason I'd be going absolute full strength this week and in the R16 match, if that means sending a rotated side up to Sale then so be it, our young guns put on a show there in the PRC, I'm sure Richards, Hennessey, Butt, Griffin, Frost, Bayliss, Staddon et al would match up well against them.
Quote:theredseatQuote:ShortyinBurnham
Have just seen that McCall has confirmed that Itoje and George will definitely not play on Friday. He didn't mention any of the other returning Internationals though.
Can't wait, should be a great game!
Posted in other thread but this from The Times implies Earl will be involved given it's a very different message to the one about George and Itoje:
"On Earl, who played 369 of 400 possible Six Nations minutes, McCall said: “He obviously had a great tournament. He’s feeling really good about his rugby. He’s one of the ones who shone all the way through. He’s in the building this week but he will get a week off in the next three weeks.”
Talk about mixed messaging.
To confirm: we don't have to rest anyone vs Sarries, they all just need a mandatory rest week in next 3 fixtures?
If that's the case, we go as strong as possible for home games surely. Especially against a play-off rival.
Sela not mentioned specifically here so hopefully he's included
[www.somersetlive.co.uk]
Quote:theredseatQuote:ShortyinBurnham
Have just seen that McCall has confirmed that Itoje and George will definitely not play on Friday. He didn't mention any of the other returning Internationals though.
Can't wait, should be a great game!
Posted in other thread but this from The Times implies Earl will be involved given it's a very different message to the one about George and Itoje:
"On Earl, who played 369 of 400 possible Six Nations minutes, McCall said: “He obviously had a great tournament. He’s feeling really good about his rugby. He’s one of the ones who shone all the way through. He’s in the building this week but he will get a week off in the next three weeks.”
Talk about mixed messaging.
To confirm: we don't have to rest anyone vs Sarries, they all just need a mandatory rest week in next 3 fixtures?
If that's the case, we go as strong as possible for home games surely. Especially against a play-off rival.
I'd like to see us mix and match a bit on resting players eg alternating Spencer and Finn's rest but JvG has always gone more towards more mass rotation for one game in the past so that seems more likely again now especially with two home and one away games
[www.rugbypass.com]
Let's hope he is back in the next few weeks as archie will need to sit out a game presumably
JvG will mix & match to ensure the players get the right rest and I am positive about that but not at the expense of the team and we can be assured whichever 23 he puts out will be strong and very competitive the rest is up to the rugby gods.
We as supporters can do our bit by making both home games against Sarries as hostile an environment as we can and cheer our boys to hopefully 2 wins.
Come on Bath
Maybe Finn goes off after 50 and Santi goes to 10. Maybe we’re doing ok so Ben can have 20 minutes rest (19 more than usual!). But the vibe of JvG’s words this week is that everyone’s back and ready to go, and this is the game we’re targeting for 5 points, no excuses.
I’m fine with that. I’d love it in fact as it looks a dry spring night at The Rec and I cannot wait to watch the first XV back at it. I’d go:
Beno, Dunn, Sela, Roux, Ewels, Hill, Underhill, Reid
Spencer, Russell, Muir, Mojo, Lawrence, Arundell, TDG
Kepu, VV, TDT, Richards, Bayliss, BVDL, Santi, Alfie.
Come on you Bath!
I am guessing that means we go weaker away at Sale next week. I think I would rather go marginally weaker against Saracens and marginally stronger against Sale and try to garner say collectively 6+ points.
But as I am going to be at the Rec, as you say on dry, crisp evening, let's go and celebrate our new shareholder coming on board with some champagne rugby.
Bath Rugby: 1 Beno Obano, 2 Tom Dunn, 3 Archie Griffin, 4 Quinn Roux, 5 Charlie Ewels, 6 Josh Bayliss, 7 Miles Reid, 8 Alfie Barbeary, 9 Ben Spencer (c), 10 Finn Russell, 11 Will Muir, 12 Max Ojomoh, 13 Ollie Lawrence, 14 Henry Arundell, 15 Tom de Glanville
Replacements: 16 Kepu Tuipulotu, 17 Francois van Wyk, 18 Archie Griffin, 19 Ted Hill, 20 Guy Pepper, 21 Bernard van der Linde, 22 Santi Carreras, 23 Sam Underhill
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Very surprised that we have started with Spencer and Finn. Santi Carreras must be wondering why on earth he joined Bath Rugby.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:19:11:38:46 by BathMatt53.
1 Eroni Mawi
2 Theo Dan
3 Marcus Street
4 Nick Isiekwe
5 Hugh Tizard
6 Theo McFarland
7 Juan Martin Gonzalez
8 Tom Willis
9 Ivan Van Zyl (c)
10 Owen Farrell
11 Rotimi Segun
12 Nick Tompkins
13 Lucio Cinti
14 Tobias Elliott
15 Elliot Daly
Replacements:
16 James Hadfield
17 Alex O'Driscoll
18 Marco Riccioni
19 Andy Onyeama-Christie
20 Ben Earl
21 Gareth Simpson
22 Fergus Burke
23 Max Malins
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:19:11:39:55 by BathMatt53.
Assume Sela has a knock as dropped out of Wider England Squad and not appeared for Bath since.
That Saracens bench seems to be one of the smallest I can remember seeing for a Prem game. Imagine their front row are being lined up to go deep into the game - O'Driscoll getting his Prem debut against du Toit is quite the introduction...
Quote:Benisjammin
Apart from their back row which is frightening that looks like a slightly weakened Saracens team IMHO.
Our back row on the bench is OK as well. 19 Ted Hill, 20 Guy Pepper, 23 Sam Underhill. Should be a cracker.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Saracens look strong but their bench not the same level.
Quote:We’ll rest them for Enya! Sale Away.tigersimon
No rest for your 6N internationals!
Assume Sela has a knock as dropped out of Wider England Squad and not appeared for Bath since.
Are you trying to get a rise from Mr Herox Opti ? 😘
Widcombe Garçon
Quote:BathMatt53
Archie Griffin sub and starter which is impressive.
Very surprised that we have started with Spencer and Finn. Santi Carreras must be wondering why on earth he joined Bath Rugby.
Not at all. He knows his time will come.
.
100%
He will no doubt travel in v understrength 23 to sale away in yet another 'against the odds' opp for him.
Really interested to see that 23 as will still have a lot of quality.
Hopefully kirk, frost, sela, richards, staddon, green, butt, hennessey etc will be involved and will be a tough test for them.
Quote:tigersimon
No rest for your 6N internationals!
Assume Sela has a knock as dropped out of Wider England Squad and not appeared for Bath since.
Sela played in the prem cup against Gloucester, can't remember if he featured against Tigers or Bedford though.
van Wyk, Frost, TdT, Richards, Ewels, Hill, Staddon, Barbeary, TCS, Carreras, Muir, Redpath, Hennessey, Cokanasiga, TdG
Kepu, Kirk, Sela / Griffin, Roux / Enoch, Reid, BVL, Butt, Green
Quote:gaz59
I'm not sure what the backs lineup will be if Ollie doesn't last full match
I'm also not sure who is going to 8.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:byQuote:tigersimon
No rest for your 6N internationals!
Assume Sela has a knock as dropped out of Wider England Squad and not appeared for Bath since.
Sela played in the prem cup against Gloucester, can't remember if he featured against Tigers or Bedford though.
Sela not involved in Tigers or Bedford games.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:BathMatt53
Yes I think thats why Lahiff was called up for England (and / or Kloska)?
Both were involved, Lahiff when Kloska (& others) was involved with England A.
Then Kloska was with the Wider England training camp.
Quote:OutsideBath
Good to see Bath at full strength and Sarries not quite, let’s hope there’s no repeat of the Saints debacle where Bath just didn’t turn up
Let’s hope not. We will no doubt be somewhat rusty whereas Saracens could have played that entire team in training matches over the last few weeks!
Don't think it matters greatly either way. Plenty of different ways to prepare and it's only with hindsight that these things become 'obvious' what a coach should have done
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
What a high quality game- Sarries have played brilliantly at times
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
Pretty impressive stuff this.
... IMHO, of course.
Now in Honolulu
We forgive him
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
Hope FvW ok.
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
Quote:hasta
I genuinely don't think Sarries have been that bad. We've been excellent, particular in defence.
Hope FvW ok.
They haven’t and against any other team they are probably in the running to win. Our defence in the 22 was so ferocious it forced the errors and our transition tonight was electric
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
So many players had good games!
Great to see Ollie and Horse looking really sharp again.
Alfie has really carried on his form from Europe and made me even sadder he is leaving, but clearly Saracens see him as the ideal replacement for Willis and have paid him top dollar to make the move.
My MotM - it basically could have been anyone in a numbered BBW shirt but, primum inter pares, - Josh Bayliss. There when we needed him, doing everything brilliantly, for the entire time he was on the pitch. How he does not get more recognition is beyond me.
... IMHO, of course.
Now in Honolulu
Nothing to do with which teams might be there you understand, had always intended to go
What happened with van Wyk?
Quote:theredseat
Away for the weekend so following updates and looking forward to settling in to watch this one back soon. Sounds like we produced some superb stuff
What happened with van Wyk?
Twisted his ankle out of a maul. Hopefully it's nothing major.
Thought Saracens played well (their line out, scrum and attacking patterns were sharp), but just incredible defense and an all court attacking game proved far too much. Scary thing is that we still have room for improvement... can't believe Bayliss missed that pass for what would have been a try of the season!
Hope FvW ok, didn't look in too much pain sat down, and kudos to Beno for playing the whole 80. Just a great Fri night and a warm feeling that things are starting to click at the right time...
Now we’re playing like that, the Rec a picture, smiles all around, beating good teams like Sarries by 50, Dyson’s long term capital inbound, stadium happening, European dreaming…
Enjoy it. Just enjoy nights like tonight. In an uncertain and pretty bleak world, how lucky we are and what fun it is, which is what sport is and always should be.
I'd feared a loss but not on that scale.
Sadly we have hitched our future to Farrell Jnr as player and coach and so can expect midtable for the foreseeable future if we're lucky.
Good luck for the rest of the season.
That was as complete a performance from 1 to 23 as we’ll see all season.
Josh Bayliss was omnipotent. Finn Russell a magician. Ollie looks to have found his form. BvdL looks like a feisty pain in the @#$%& back up 9.
Saracens used to be our bogey team, but now seem to be our bunnies.
Loved every minute of that.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:20:22:09:04 by @Hydor18.
Weirdly even with the full court game and exceptional tries we left a few points out there .... plus our defence was just brutal.
Sarries are a weird team, they base so much of their attacking game around Farrell and Daly, neither of whom are spring chickens .... it is hard to remember anything that their centres did. I think bringing back Farrell is proving a retrograde step.

Should be an honourable man of the match for Beno - not often you have to demand 80 minutes of a prop and he looked absolutely done in by the end. Don't think he'll be moving much tomorrow.
Mr Finn Russell may not be known for his drop goals but he can sure pull a 50:22 out of the bag.
Quote:Toast and Marmite
Gods our midfield defence is poor tonight
That's hilarious 😂
Quote:shipwrecked
I'm willing to bet Henry Arundell did a little mental fist pump when he picked off Owen Farrell's pass for the intercept try given the fact he was allegedly told to 'chase those ****ing kicks' by Farrell during a training session prior to the World Cup.
Some lovely comments from Henry at the end about JVG and the Bath environment - worth looking for if you didn't see them. Very well put for a guy that had just been running around for 80 minutes.
Quote:@Hydor18
BvdL looks like a feisty pain in the @#$%& back up 9.
He's giving Pollock a run for his money as a wind up merchant.
Any idea why the high challenge by Sarries in the first half wasn’t checked by the TMO?
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:21:07:37:04 by OutsideBath.
Quote:shipwrecked
I'm willing to bet Henry Arundell did a little mental fist pump when he picked off Owen Farrell's pass for the intercept try given the fact he was allegedly told to 'chase those ****ing kicks' by Farrell during a training session prior to the World Cup.
[www.instagram.com]
Quote:View from the North
A tip of the hat to Matt Carley tonight. Quite a straightforward night, but used the TMO sparingly, helped the game flow with his communication, and importantly didn’t let anyone else try to ref the game for him.
He did have a very good game overall and actually I didn't think it was straightforward. To me there seemed to be 'stuff' bubbling along but the way he managed and reffed the game ensured it didn't break out
The one issue I had was lineouts. 3 or 4 Sarries lineouts to me looked equally crooked to the two he called against us [and all seemed to be contested]
Giving Sarries such a thumping is wonderful. I remember the October 2021 game when they had 45 points on the board at HT and won 17-71. It was the lowest of the lows in those dark seasons. The JVG turnaround is incredible - 8 of the XV who started that 2021 horror show played last night, 7 of them as starters and Sam on the bench.
To reply to Paul above, I have a suspicion that Farrell (like his old man) will be a superb coach/DOR in time.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:21:06:46:14 by Rokobilly.
- I picked a great first game to attend live last night. Weather was beautiful, food was lovely, and the rugby was especially fantastic! Credit to the good natured Saracens fans around me who took the result in good nature
- Bayliss and Arundell were everywhere last night, the ability we have to break a line with outright speed across the team is fantastic, and we have several players now who can stand up a man (or two or three) and then break or find the right pass
- Finn was just magical, again. Spencer looked solid, and in BvdL it looks like he can have a bit of a rest and not play 79+ every week
- Farrell looked slow. Like, really slow. I lost count of how many times he got the ball stood still and just passed to the next man without even taking a step. Daly looked tired. He was right in front of me during the warm up and even then he looked shattered.
Overall a fantastic game. I had a slight nervousness that this could be a banana skin, but the 5 points proves me very wrong!
Quote:View from the North
A tip of the hat to Matt Carley tonight. Quite a straightforward night, but used the TMO sparingly, helped the game flow with his communication, and importantly didn’t let anyone else try to ref the game for him.
Agree he’s a much better ref these days and seemed to get most decisions correct. Find him frustratingly picky at times though, pulling Ben Spence back for taking a penalty about 50mm from the correct spot was annoying.
Did enjoy him marching Sarries back 10m for backchat though.
Quote:well iit was…for the first 15 minutes! 😂gaz59Quote:Toast and Marmite
Gods our midfield defence is poor tonight
That's hilarious 😂
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
As usual our 22 defence was immense and stood up to the test nicely. Not easy when you’ve got Willis barrelling down your channel!
Some work ons for definite, but as the first hit out it was a blinder.
Also makes me think about 5 points against Sale is very possible. The rest of the league will have taken not of that performance!
Faz Jnr kills back play & has been one of the most overrated players in years. No surprise that he flopped in France.
Bath need to back this up against a stronger & wiser Sarries in 2 weeks.
Quote:Toast and MarmiteQuote:well iit was…for the first 15 minutes! 😂gaz59Quote:Toast and Marmite
Gods our midfield defence is poor tonight
That's hilarious 😂
They did cut through the middle a couple of times, which was frustrating at the time. Guess even good defences get beaten some times. Sure those Sarries line breaks will be reviewed on Monday.
What was most pleasing, final score aside, was our backs looking more dangerous in attack than they have all season.
Lineout was a bit iffy again, but hey you can’t have everything.
Also how pleasing and is it that Bath have a team able to adapt so quickly during a match.
’’Paint the whole world with a rainbow”
Our conclusion was that Carley was right. In the olden days "when the dinosaurs roamed the earth" you had to take penalties from exactly where the Ref marked it or it would be a scrum for the opposition.
It irritates the hell out of me that no player takes touch kicks from the mark. What they do is start at the mark and then take 2 or 3 paces and then kick.
Outside Bath its like that professional golfer marking has ball and then moving forward for a putt...I acknowledge he took the pi*s but if its not in the right place its not in the right place.
I acknowledge that no scrum half puts the ball in straight and only once or twice a season is a scrumhalf penalised for not straight. The Law is there just ignored by everyone.
I am now very nervous about 2 weeks time.......
It was a nice surprise to see that a second big screen has been added in the ground. The right hand side third is not visible from my seat, but when combined with the original big screen where the bottom left hand corner is blocked I can now see the whole picture by quickly changing the end of the pitch I look at!! Which is certainly an improvement for TMO decisions where the action in question was often in the obscured corner.
The game reminded me a bit of Saints at ours, one of those days where everything goes wrong for one team and everything right for the other - I am in no doubt that it won’t be like that in a couple of weeks when Sarries will be out for revenge. When they pull themselves together after this result they can give anyone a game.
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:BathRob
As usual our 22 defence was immense and stood up to the test nicely. Not easy when you’ve got Willis barrelling down your channel!
Sam Warburton mentioned a stat after the game that Willis had 12 carries but only made 14 metres, not sure if 2nd half or whole game, but he was effectively stopped in his tracks by our defence. Alfie on the other hand was barrelling over the gain line and taking two defenders with him to set up front foot ball. Alfie must surely make an England squad this summer 🤔
Given he's going to be a coach too his impact is going to be inescapable.
Quote:I think you could well be right but in my view he should have taken the O'Gara route of coaching elsewhere initially and being judged purely on his merits rather than unquestioningly as he is, in my view, at Sarries.Rokobilly
To reply to Paul above, I have a suspicion that Farrell (like his old man) will be a superb coach/DOR in time.
Anyway this is Bath board and that was a great performance. I really hope we are better in a fortnights time but I suspect JVG & Co will have fixed the few issues and we will not have fixed the larger ones.
It might be all on Carre scoring a double hattrick from inside our 22!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:21:10:11:53 by PaulHerox.
Just superb rugby from the gods 🇪🇪
Widcombe Garçon


Fab should be nowhere near the England Squad. What pace he had has gone. The result should also bust the myth that his present inspire the work rate of those around him. Bath out worked them. After the 6N the were comments we wouldn't have lost like that with him driving standards. Clearly not true
Tom Willis can be stopped and was out played by Alfie. While he had a good summer he was still largely unproven at international level. Has been good in PREM but internationals a step up. He has clearly benefited form becoming much more vital ro England when unavailable than when he was like his brother , Zac Mercier and others before him.
Very few sides could live with a bench like ours. It’s a truly devastating weapon and the rugby purist in me thinks there’s a definite argument to rein it in so fatigue plays much more of role in the game.
Agree that Carley had an excellent game - he does seem to say a lot "for the benefit of the tape" but that helps my understanding (and it might be to stop the TMO butting in!). Heard him say after the final whistle, in response to thanks from a player that he'd enjoyed it.
Players shouldn't constantly ask for penalties but there is a more sympathetic way of telling them to back off.
Ben was even more geared up for the game than usual and was deemed to be constantly badgering Carley for penalties .... which he does tend to do. Carley had enough after a while and told him to pack it in .... I think Ben might have become too vociferous as he got frustrated.
Contrast that to watching Sara Cox who really seems to enjoy player interaction.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2026:03:21:15:56:05 by Never In Doubt.
It does seem like the game has moved on enormously since the last World Cup and I struggle to imagine teams being successful in this new era without a creative playmaker at 10 – we are so lucky to have Finn!
The only slight negative was FvW going off, but sounds like it was actually due to a nasty cut on his leg as opposed to something muscular, so fingers crossed it'll be a few weeks on the sidelines as opposed to a season ender.
Quote:hasta
Faz was an incredible player, but I don't really know if it's injury or just age. Hard not to say that his last season at Sarries wasn't great, his trip to Racing was a disaster and his return to Sarries is not exactly what everyone would have hoped.
Can’t disagree with this. In fact, it kind of sums Sarries up full stop at the moment- some stellar players who are in the twilight of their careers or have had one too many injuries.
It felt like the reverse of some of the darkest days under hooper.
Sarries we're the ones who looked punched out by 50 mins as we put loads more power and pace on to the pitch and holes were opening up everywhere.
Kudos again to jvg and the club- used the prem Cup v nicely, plus a friendly and come out of that period looking refreshed and sharp.
Fingers crossed for fvw- think it said he headed to hospital with a gash to the leg from a boot? If no complications would hope he would be back in a few weeks?
Quote:dcsh
Great to be back in the Premiership with a bang!
It was a nice surprise to see that a second big screen has been added in the ground. The right hand side third is not visible from my seat, but when combined with the original big screen where the bottom left hand corner is blocked I can now see the whole picture by quickly changing the end of the pitch I look at!! Which is certainly an improvement for TMO decisions where the action in question was often in the obscured corner.
+1 on appreciating the second big screen. Though I found reading the score on it from the terrace a little tricky compared to the old scoreboard.
Now though, time has caught up both in terms of age, and how the game is played now by 10. Friday night he looked tired, and out of ideas. The main tactic seemed to be him standing still and shipping it on to next man or out the back to Daly. It was Sarries (and England?) in a microcosm: older players bring experience but the cliff edge on performance is a brutal one and if you haven’t brought through the academy players (which is so so hard in an all-conquering team like Saracens or Exeter of past) then you end up with this issue.
Next year will be interesting, they’ve signed some quality players and Ventner is not exactly a shrinking violet. Could they be back? Possibly!
adopted player, 24/25 Hame Faiva. 23/24 Ted Hill. 22/23 Cam Redpath. 21/22 Max Clark. 20/21 Henry Thomas. 19/20 Max Wright. 18/19 Cooper Vuna.
Can't really see either of them properly from our seats on the back row and I'd get a sore neck trying to look between them!Quote:Agreed Susanne Had to keep looking on line for the score as I completely lost track of the score 🤣Susanne
We'd like to see the proper scoreboard back in addition to the new screen - but maybe they'd run out of sockets on the extension cordCan't really see either of them properly from our seats on the back row and I'd get a sore neck trying to look between them!
Widcombe Garçon
Quote:hasta
Someone made a comment during the 6N that if Farrell was on the pitch England would never have had a result as bad as they did. Weeeellllll....
It was tongue-in-cheek.
Honest.
He admits 6:2 splits come with risk, as does throwing on 7 of 8 after 50 mins but his decisions have rarely backfired so far tbf.
I think the psychology of its huge. I love it when we stack our bench , knowing we have that firepower on reserve, to the point where I am comfortable with some of our best players like tdt and hill being on the bench v regularly.
Sarries looked like they were running low on energy and you bring on kepu, fvw, tdt, hill, pepper, underhill and santi- brutal!
The players that start know that they can empty the tank in 50 - 55 minutes. The players that come on know they have "only" 25 - 30 minutes and can really go full out and of course are more rested if they were to start the next week.
The risk is what happened this week with FVW leaving within a few seconds of coming on and then the player who was replaced, in this case Beno having to come back and play another 30 minutes.
Quote:copester
I personally would not write Farrell off yet
I think the acceleration of quality in players coming through is, in parallel, accelerating the decline of players like Farrell and Daly. I mean, some of the elite level U18 rugby now looks technically better than International rugby looked 15 years ago. The massive professionalisation of skills training and S&C conditioning starting 8-10 years ago is now bearing fruit with young players who are just off the scale good. Borthwick's statement a few months ago about Daly's importance to the RWC27 squad is looking nonsensical. As for Farrell - a transition to a new job as 'setter of standards in training' beckons.
Quote:OptimistQuote:copester
I personally would not write Farrell off yet
I think the acceleration of quality in players coming through is, in parallel, accelerating the decline of players like Farrell and Daly. I mean, some of the elite level U18 rugby now looks technically better than International rugby looked 15 years ago. The massive professionalisation of skills training and S&C conditioning starting 8-10 years ago is now bearing fruit with young players who are just off the scale good. Borthwick's statement a few months ago about Daly's importance to the RWC27 squad is looking nonsensical. As for Farrell - a transition to a new job as 'setter of standards in training' beckons.
Certainly would agree with all of that. Just think Borthwick's default selection criteria is experience and regarding Daly, his booming 50 meter boot will score very highly
Quote:Charlieboa1
Really interesting interview with jvg and tdt after the game on use of the bench.
He admits 6:2 splits come with risk, as does throwing on 7 of 8 after 50 mins but his decisions have rarely backfired so far tbf.
I think the psychology of its huge. I love it when we stack our bench , knowing we have that firepower on reserve, to the point where I am comfortable with some of our best players like tdt and hill being on the bench v regularly.
Sarries looked like they were running low on energy and you bring on kepu, fvw, tdt, hill, pepper, underhill and santi- brutal!
Where was the interview with Johann to hear on TV or radio? Thanks
Quote:copester
I personally would not write Farrell off yet, maybe in a couple of weeks. Sarries will be a different animal fully loaded.
I would. He's a massive liability currently.
He should have retired after his French stint and whilst I understand no one would want to leave on that down note he is at real risk of tarnishing his club legacy.
Quote:Tlacey90Quote:Charlieboa1
Really interesting interview with jvg and tdt after the game on use of the bench.
He admits 6:2 splits come with risk, as does throwing on 7 of 8 after 50 mins but his decisions have rarely backfired so far tbf.
I think the psychology of its huge. I love it when we stack our bench , knowing we have that firepower on reserve, to the point where I am comfortable with some of our best players like tdt and hill being on the bench v regularly.
Sarries looked like they were running low on energy and you bring on kepu, fvw, tdt, hill, pepper, underhill and santi- brutal!
Where was the interview with Johann to hear on TV or radio? Thanks
It came up on my Facebook feed via the bath supporters group.
Think it may be on Somerset live
9 Charlie Bracken
10 Owen Farrell
11 Rotimi Segun
12 Nick Tompkins
13 Lucio Cinti
14 Tobias Elliott
15 Elliot Daly
[24/25 adoptee: Francois van Wyk]
Quote:BathMatt53
Very surprised that Sarries have gone for Farrell again at 10 vs Saints. In fact most of the same back line. could be another cricket score with Saints putting out their Internationals.
9 Charlie Bracken
10 Owen Farrell
11 Rotimi Segun
12 Nick Tompkins
13 Lucio Cinti
14 Tobias Elliott
15 Elliot Daly
Another Sarries loss and they can kiss goodbye to the playoffs.
Quote:OutsideBath
Another Sarries loss and they can kiss goodbye to the playoffs.
I'd be amazed if Sarries get anything out of the game.
And therefore if they make the playoffs.
BATH supporter since 1975
Adopted players:
2015/6 Tom Homer
2016/7 Matt Banahan
2017/8 Jeff Williams
2018/9 Victor Delmas
2019/20 Semesa Rokoduguni
2020/21 Will Stuart
