3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
By Syco Bill
March 29 2009
After awakening at 5.00am by mistake awaiting for F1, my enthusiasm for the first ever race was underway. For us Brits, it was great to see F1 back on the BBC, with no interruptions, although the intro could be worked on. Anyway, as the race started Lewis Hamilton had a lot of work to do, as he started from 18th, due to a gear box change that saw him demoted to 18th place in qualifying yesterday.
Lewis was able to bring himself up to 11th by the second lap. He continued to attack his McLaren-Mercedes to its full potential and even beyond to bring himself up to 4th by the end of the race.
When Kubica and Vettel (who I had bets on to win) crashed out at turn 3 with only 3 laps to go, making me very angry and making the safety car deploy. The official timings however claimed that Hamilton was 3rd, but suddenly changed to 4th.
After the race, officials have decided to penalise Juano Trulli and smack him with a 25 second penalty leaving him feeling low in twelth place. Trulli had apparently according to sources slid of the track after managing to retain his 3rd spot behind the safety car allowing Hamilton through. Trulli obviously thought that he was entitled to retake his position and overtook Hamilton during the safety car, which is not allowed.
The McLaren Mercedes team also saw Hekki Kovalinen have to retire after the turn one incident involving him knocking into Reubens Barrichello who then pushed into Mark Webber, who took out Nick Heidfeld and forced the Spaniard Alonso to vacate the incident using the grass.
In conclusion in this race we have seen that the McLaren Mercedes team have a lot of work to do to be as fast as the Brawn GP team, however with Lewis able to overtake using his supreme skills, we could see McLaren back at the top soon. Hopefully Hekki still has the fighting spirit in him.
3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: McLaren Fans (IP Logged)
Date: 29/03/2009 13:12
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: kurtinu (IP Logged)
Date: 29/03/2009 19:59
Gr8 driving Hamilton!
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: hammerthief (IP Logged)
Date: 29/03/2009 20:10
more than a tiny bit lucky and if JT version of events is right, i think he will recover his 3rd place...but a jolly good drive and showed his CLASS! only 13th fastest lap but still in top 5 finishers...
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Parminio_USA (IP Logged)
Date: 29/03/2009 21:14
Jarno has a very selective memory. The reason he was penalized is because he went off the track. After he went off the track, Lewis passed him. After he returned to the track, he just figured that he had the right to pass Lewis back.
He figured wrong.
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
He figured wrong.
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: In The Pits (IP Logged)
Date: 29/03/2009 22:37
Hard luck, but still a great drive from Trulli. Kimi looks to have continued last years carelessness.
Well done Lewis, that was a champions drive..
Well done Lewis, that was a champions drive..
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: De_JOKKE (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 01:44
Lewis you're the man!!!
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: jackgarrett (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 13:12
Yep , i still amazed he did it. Champs drive alright. We never seen him start for so far back in F1 and gets 3rd in a bleow average car.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Parminio_USA (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 14:01
Yep , i still amazed he did it. Champs drive alright. We never seen him start for so far back in F1 and gets 3rd in a bleow average car.
I'm not too sure about it being a below average car, but you do make a very good point.
Personally, I was just hoping like hell he could secure a point or two...and I wasn't really sure if he could do it or not.
I was VERY happy with 4th. A fantastic result. To get 3rd the way he did isn't what you like to see, but that's racing. I'll take it.
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
I'm not too sure about it being a below average car, but you do make a very good point.
Personally, I was just hoping like hell he could secure a point or two...and I wasn't really sure if he could do it or not.
I was VERY happy with 4th. A fantastic result. To get 3rd the way he did isn't what you like to see, but that's racing. I'll take it.
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: In The Pits (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 17:21
Quote:parm
To get 3rd the way he did isn't what you like to see,
Trulli went off the track then passed under a yellow. - Not Hamiltons fault. For once the stewards got it right.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009:03:30:17:23:04 by In The Pits.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: negotiator (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 17:31
err hello
today hamilton admits mcclaren told him to let trulli pass
'Let Trulli through', McLaren told Hamilton
30 March 2009 / Results / Photos
Lewis Hamilton has explained that his team instructed him to allow Jarno Trulli to repass him during the Australian Grand Prix on Sunday. Trulli, who finished third at the end of the race, was handed a 25-second penalty for passing the McLaren under safety car conditions on the penultimate lap of the race.
The confusion between the two drivers began at the end of lap 56, when the safety car had been deployed follow the collision between Sebastian Vettel and Robert Kubica. Trulli - running third - overshot at Turn 15, skipping across the grass as Hamilton passed the Totota which, in turn, retook his position behind the safety car, claiming that the the World Champion's McLaren slowed and moved off the racing line, as if with a technical problem.
With the Italian devastated over the loss of his third place, Hamilton gave his view of events to SpeedTV: "I was behind Trulli under the safety car, and clearly you're not allowed to overtake under the safety car but he went off in the second to last corner - he went wide and onto the grass, I guess his tyres were cold. I slowed down as much as I could, but was forced to go by. I was then told to let him back past, but I don't know if that's in the regulations and, if it isn't, I should really have had third on the road."
[f1.gpupdate.net]
What a farce.
today hamilton admits mcclaren told him to let trulli pass
'Let Trulli through', McLaren told Hamilton
30 March 2009 / Results / Photos
Lewis Hamilton has explained that his team instructed him to allow Jarno Trulli to repass him during the Australian Grand Prix on Sunday. Trulli, who finished third at the end of the race, was handed a 25-second penalty for passing the McLaren under safety car conditions on the penultimate lap of the race.
The confusion between the two drivers began at the end of lap 56, when the safety car had been deployed follow the collision between Sebastian Vettel and Robert Kubica. Trulli - running third - overshot at Turn 15, skipping across the grass as Hamilton passed the Totota which, in turn, retook his position behind the safety car, claiming that the the World Champion's McLaren slowed and moved off the racing line, as if with a technical problem.
With the Italian devastated over the loss of his third place, Hamilton gave his view of events to SpeedTV: "I was behind Trulli under the safety car, and clearly you're not allowed to overtake under the safety car but he went off in the second to last corner - he went wide and onto the grass, I guess his tyres were cold. I slowed down as much as I could, but was forced to go by. I was then told to let him back past, but I don't know if that's in the regulations and, if it isn't, I should really have had third on the road."
[f1.gpupdate.net]
What a farce.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: TommySK (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 17:41
Well, I think Lewis did the right thing. Last season we have seen Lewis penalised on every possible (and some impossible) occasions, so it is no wonder the team wants to play it safe...
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: In The Pits (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 17:41
Err Hello,
just bcause the team told him to let trulli pass dont mean that trulli was allowed to under the rules.
They were behind the safety car. Not McLarens call.
just bcause the team told him to let trulli pass dont mean that trulli was allowed to under the rules.
They were behind the safety car. Not McLarens call.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: negotiator (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 18:04
they told hami to let trulli pass, he slowed down and moved to the side of track.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: In The Pits (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 18:07
See above.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: FormulaFan (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 18:23
What was he supposed to do? Stop?
Hamilton clearly slowed and pulled to the side, so Trulli WOULD overtake him.
Hamilton clearly slowed and pulled to the side, so Trulli WOULD overtake him.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: negotiator (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 18:31
if anyone thinks trulli pulled a overtaking monouver needs thier heads examining.
Trulli knew he lost his 3rd place fair and square but when hamilton is told slow down and move aside and let trulli through, is trulli supposed to just stop on the track?
Trulli knew he lost his 3rd place fair and square but when hamilton is told slow down and move aside and let trulli through, is trulli supposed to just stop on the track?
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: hammerthief (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 18:41
no he should have slowed...then passed when LH was 10 car lengths further behind the car in front..then he has a clear problem and is breaching the running behind the safety car rules...AND then talked to his team to check he was ok...perhaps checked with Charlie Whiting but as we know thats not a very good opinion of what is right and wrong...
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: McDafthead89 (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 18:55
Now this new evidence has been released, it clearly shows that Lewis let him pass. The stewards should re-look at this and maybe just demote Trulli to 4th. Thats totally unfair on Trulli.
Billy
McLaren Addicts - The new, revived Forum for McLaren Fans!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009:03:30:21:29:09 by Syco Bill.
Billy
McLaren Addicts - The new, revived Forum for McLaren Fans!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009:03:30:21:29:09 by Syco Bill.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: negotiator (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 19:00
exactly at least give trulli 4th, this is clearly mclarens fault if they only carried on and took 3rd and trulli took 4th everyone would go home happy eg macca trulli toyota lewis, stewards fia and the fans.
But no macca had to be dumb about it.
But no macca had to be dumb about it.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: mocca (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 19:09
Stop being such a sook. It's not Macca's fault it's the stewards who make the decision's along with the FIA who are at fault.
Gold hammerthief
Quote:perhaps checked with Charlie Whiting but as we know thats not a very good opinion of what is right and wrong...
Gold hammerthief
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: In The Pits (IP Logged)
Date: 30/03/2009 20:26
I agree with Syco Bill, place him fourth.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: hammerthief (IP Logged)
Date: 31/03/2009 00:18
Quote:negotiator
exactly at least give trulli 4th, this is clearly mclarens fault if they only carried on and took 3rd and trulli took 4th everyone would go home happy eg macca trulli toyota lewis, stewards fia and the fans.
But no macca had to be dumb about it.
Are you blaming McLaren for Trulli being less than competant in keeping his car on the road?? Surely it was dumb to drive off the road at less than racing speed behind a saftey car...then allow yourself to be conned into repassing a competitor and then not finding out if you ought to let him back past before the end of the race?? I think both teams were dumb, too catious etc...unless mcLaren were being clever and conned Trulli into a mistake that cost him valuable points at the end of the season??
There are two sides to every story and you come here moaning about McLaren as usual....Perhaps the drivers behind LH thought Trulli should have stayed off the track until they had all gone past or he might have caused an avoidable accident coming back on into the train of cars behind the saftey car...
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Johan Hasselberg (IP Logged)
Date: 31/03/2009 02:52
Stewards was wrong (again). And it's sad for both McLaren and Toyota. Jarno really deserved a good result after a strong race from him.
Johan
Johan
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Hall_Green_Wolf (IP Logged)
Date: 31/03/2009 08:29
Quote:negotiator
exactly at least give trulli 4th, this is clearly mclarens fault if they only carried on and took 3rd and trulli took 4th everyone would go home happy eg macca trulli toyota lewis, stewards fia and the fans.
But no macca had to be dumb about it.
Clearly mclarens fault? Have a day off mate its was trulli that caused the confusion. Mclaren just played it safe, toyota should have asked the question immediately then that would have gave trulli a chance to let lewis go back past.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: McDafthead89 (IP Logged)
Date: 31/03/2009 12:18
Well I think McLaren are at fault for letting him back past, but then Toyota should have gone to the stewards and asked for their opinion. Also due to using slicks, it is harder to keep the tyres warm, making it harder to stay on the track.
Confusion was met at the GP but it could have easily been sorted by putting Trulli 4th and promoting Hamilton to 3rd.
Billy
Confusion was met at the GP but it could have easily been sorted by putting Trulli 4th and promoting Hamilton to 3rd.
Billy
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: YCX (IP Logged)
Date: 31/03/2009 18:30
Don't forget guy's it was Mclaren that filed the complaint against Trulli.
This thing smells. Who does this sort of things, first saying that Hamilton has to stop and let Trulli pass and then file a complaint against Trulli for passing him.
The stuwards wouldn't have done anyting against it if it wasn't becouse of mclaren Complaint.
I accept that Trulli is now 12 and Hamilton is now 3. This is sport and in sport there will alway's be people or teams cheating there way up.
This thing smells. Who does this sort of things, first saying that Hamilton has to stop and let Trulli pass and then file a complaint against Trulli for passing him.
The stuwards wouldn't have done anyting against it if it wasn't becouse of mclaren Complaint.
I accept that Trulli is now 12 and Hamilton is now 3. This is sport and in sport there will alway's be people or teams cheating there way up.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Johan Hasselberg (IP Logged)
Date: 31/03/2009 22:25
Hall_Green_Wolf - You are very, very wrong. Can't understand you in any point. If you really are thinking this way, it is a catastrophe. All top 5 drivers deserved the result. It was just great. What's wrong with you, go away...
Johan
Johan
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Hall_Green_Wolf (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 08:18
Quote:Johan Hasselberg
Hall_Green_Wolf - You are very, very wrong. Can't understand you in any point. If you really are thinking this way, it is a catastrophe. All top 5 drivers deserved the result. It was just great. What's wrong with you, go away...
Johan
Who the fu5k do you think you are telling me to go away you jumped up little pr!ck. Thats my opinion and i am entitled to it as you are yours.
Whats wrong with me? Muppets like you thats what. If your ever in birmingham england come visit me and we will talk about it
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Hall_Green_Wolf (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 11:11
Toyota have held there hands up and decided not to appeal the desicion.
So who is very very wrong now mr johan. Whats wrong with you..............go away.
So who is very very wrong now mr johan. Whats wrong with you..............go away.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Parminio_USA (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 13:31
DOWN BOY! Dooooooown. Dooooooooooooooooooooooooooooown. Sit....staaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay.
GOOD BOY!
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
GOOD BOY!
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Hall_Green_Wolf (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 13:55
Im ok now my master has taken me for a walk lol.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Parminio_USA (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 14:07
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: In The Pits (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 14:39
The stewards are the real people to blame here.
Due to their unfair treatment of McLaren at every opportunity these last few years [since they started challenging Ferrari], the McLaren team has become very nervous about being punished for the slightest thing.
Thats why, when Lewis passed trulli, [even though trulli ran off track] they erred on the side of caution and told Lewis to let him re-pass.
It happened so quick, maybe the engineer didn't see trulli off track and thought they would get DQ'd
Due to their unfair treatment of McLaren at every opportunity these last few years [since they started challenging Ferrari], the McLaren team has become very nervous about being punished for the slightest thing.
Thats why, when Lewis passed trulli, [even though trulli ran off track] they erred on the side of caution and told Lewis to let him re-pass.
It happened so quick, maybe the engineer didn't see trulli off track and thought they would get DQ'd
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Parminio_USA (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 15:58
That is my precise thought as well. But the fact of the matter is, it's not McLaren's job to let Trulli know where he should or shouldn't be.
It's Toyota's job to see to it that they do the right thing, no matter what McLaren does.
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
It's Toyota's job to see to it that they do the right thing, no matter what McLaren does.
Regards,
Parminio
New McLaren Fans Forum: McLaren Fans
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: danielm (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 20:22
Yes and Toyota did the rigth thing. If a car has a problem you pass it, Trulli did nothing wrong.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: hammerthief (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 20:58
what problem did the McLaren have? was it more than 10 car lengths behind the car in front? Toyota did the wrong thing...until the stewards say otherwise, you'll just have to keep moaning but it won't change anything...
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Johan Hasselberg (IP Logged)
Date: 01/04/2009 21:27
I have been a McLaren fan for all my life and last year I supported Hamilton 100 % for the title. He really deserved it and I was soooo happy. But now McLaren pay back with lies and cheat against Jarno Trulli and if Jarno don't is given back his 3:rd position (his right), I will sadly change my opinion about McLaren. That is really sad after all the years I loved the team and the drivers in the team. I still will be happy for Hamiltons last year, but this year also Jarno Trulli and Jenson Button will drive for WDC, and Jarno is my greatest hero in Formula 1, after Riccardo Patreses all fantastic years.
1. Jenson Button 2. Rubens Barrichello 3. Jarno Trulli 4. Lewis Hamilton 5. Timo Glock
That is it.
Johan
1. Jenson Button 2. Rubens Barrichello 3. Jarno Trulli 4. Lewis Hamilton 5. Timo Glock
That is it.
Johan
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Hall_Green_Wolf (IP Logged)
Date: 02/04/2009 00:01
So you will let one stewards decision affect your feelings for your team.
What utter rubbish. In that case Mclaren do not need fans like you. Go away,
What utter rubbish. In that case Mclaren do not need fans like you. Go away,
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: negotiator (IP Logged)
Date: 02/04/2009 00:33
wow does cheating follow macca around or macca follows around cheating.
You guys have racked up enough lies and cheats and espionage and millions of pounds of fines but macca still carries on.
You guys have racked up enough lies and cheats and espionage and millions of pounds of fines but macca still carries on.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Hall_Green_Wolf (IP Logged)
Date: 02/04/2009 00:36
Trulli went off track at snails pace, more fool him.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: hammerthief (IP Logged)
Date: 02/04/2009 10:10
Quote:hammerthief
more than a tiny bit lucky and if JT version of events is right, i think he will recover his 3rd place...but a jolly good drive and showed his CLASS! only 13th fastest lap but still in top 5 finishers...
As i said 4 days ago...oh well.
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: Johan Hasselberg (IP Logged)
Date: 02/04/2009 11:09
Now everything is good and I take back what I said before. I'm just sad for Hamilton lost his points, because he like Trulli drove excellent in this race. Anyway I hope on a good F1 seson from now with no more wrong stewards.
Let It Rock
Johan
Let It Rock
Johan
Re: 3rd for Hamilton after Trulli penalised
Posted by: negotiator (IP Logged)
Date: 02/04/2009 13:27
nah i'm happy, but macca are really funny though.