Charlton Athletic v Tranmere Rovers Match Discussion

What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011:10:11:18:35:27 by Deadly Submarine.

can only see a comfortable home win 3 1 to them

3-1 is what I have gone for on the Prediction League also!

We'll raise our game and get at least a draw! SWA!

know ever the optimist but think we'll ready for this ! and did they have a tough cup game ?!?!? 1 - 2

Sounds as tho we're doing well !

excellent ! well deserved

more of the same second half

Well done for the first half now it`s time to brick up Fon Williams goal because they(Charlton) will come out all guns blazing just got to keep our headsnot fall asleep and if poss pinch another goal Baxter to add that one and that will do a 2-0 win come on you whites.

ooo harsh Pen ! c'mon Tranmere !

Very pleasing performance today from the Lads ! think we can feel we were robbed really ! but that's how it is ! still great tho !
interesting to see Accy have a man sent off, then came from 2 down to get a draw with ten men !

Again ref turns the game with pen(those things we fail to get we must fall down wrong way) apart from that good result if we play against any team with the same effort that has not got Charlton`s quality in the future we should get one or two wins under the belt in all things being equal we are going to batter some one day.(Oldham would be good)

Great performance, but it deserved another 1 or 2 goals from Tranmere.

Again another penalty appears to rob Tranmere, just like it has with County, Carlisle and Preston. That's an average of 1 point every 3 league games.

Keep it up and referees will cost Tranmere around 15 points this season, because they have not redressed the balance once with a penalty for Tranmere and at this rate Les will be doing a Moyes and carping directly to the FA about getting zilch penalties .

I think now perhaps Les neeeds to explore the option of a loan striker though, or perhaps replace Labadie with Welsh, slot Labadie in Baxter's place and put Baxter upfront.

Then I ate his Liver.......... with some baked beans and a can of coke.

was it Swindle sorry swindons manager said he was going to tell his players to dive more !! hope the FA take action ! there's enough play acting without him saying that ! shocking !!!

I will make my own judgement when I've seen the penalty.Have all of you who have already made comments on the matter actually been to the match.

The referees will not cost us anything like as many points as the strikers[and others]who don't get their shots on target anything like as often as they should.

Quote:

Hoots Mon
I will make my own judgement when I've seen the penalty.Have all of you who have already made comments on the matter actually been to the match.
The referees will not cost us anything like as many points as the strikers[and others]who don't get their shots on target anything like as often as they should.

Give it a rest ! go follow somerset or who ever ! sick of you being so down on my Team ! even when they have been great !

Sounds as tho we're doing well !


Say it as you SEE it.

Quote:

Hoots Mon
Sounds as tho we're doing well !

Say it as you SEE it.

think you may be trying to make a point ! tho not clear ! you don't see sounds ! you hear them, is that too complicated for you to undersatand ?

Yes Di Canio, went public and said he would tell his players to dive, because he didn't get a penalty he thought he should have in a recent match.

Frankly he should be warned by the FA for admitting to the potential promotion and use of unfair gamesmanship.

I wonder if he will ring Martin Allen and ask for tips on cheating?

Then I ate his Liver.......... with some baked beans and a can of coke.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011:10:08:22:45:37 by Matt34.

watching or listening to 5 live this morning they were saying that they expected Allans team to make a push for the top 6 !!!! do they not watch any games ! the match was it last term and PP was a disgrace !

Quote:

@gony

Quote:

Hoots Mon
Sounds as tho we're doing well !

Say it as you SEE it.

think you may be trying to make a point ! tho not clear ! you don't see sounds ! you hear them, is that too complicated for you to undersatand ?

No,my previous reply was purely in words of one syllable so that YOU would understand.

Quote:

Hoots Mon

Quote:

@gony

Quote:

Hoots Mon
Sounds as tho we're doing well !

Say it as you SEE it.

think you may be trying to make a point ! tho not clear ! you don't see sounds ! you hear them, is that too complicated for you to undersatand ?

No,my previous reply was purely in words of one syllable so that YOU would understand.

We're, possibly, and doing both have two !!! why make yourself look so daft ? well done on spelling Syllable correctly tho !!! shame you have no idea what on is tho

Quote:

Matt34
Yes Di Canio, went public and said he would tell his players to dive, because he didn't get a penalty he thought he should have in a recent match.
Frankly he should be warned by the FA for admitting to the potential promotion and use of unfair gamesmanship.

I wonder if he will ring Martin Allen and ask for tips on cheating?

Heard the bloke from Tranmere who guests along Radio Merseyside commentator.
He said a player of ours , knowing that there was someone behind, let his body go limp so he would fall on contact.
Is that what they do ?

Quote:

ivvy

Quote:

Matt34
Yes Di Canio, went public and said he would tell his players to dive, because he didn't get a penalty he thought he should have in a recent match.
Frankly he should be warned by the FA for admitting to the potential promotion and use of unfair gamesmanship.

I wonder if he will ring Martin Allen and ask for tips on cheating?

Heard the bloke from Tranmere who guests along Radio Merseyside commentator.
He said a player of ours , knowing that there was someone behind, let his body go limp so he would fall on contact.
Is that what they do ?

"Heard the bloke from Tranmere" bleadin el is this the cowsheds ?

I did go to the game and the penalty was at the other end from us so I have even less idea than most about it at this moment in time.

Overall it was a fantastic first half performance and a deserved half-time lead against a side who looked awful for an unbeaten top of the table side.

Second half though we allowed them into and although the penalty is apparently harsh, they had the momentum at the time it was given and I actually feared that if the penalty went in they would go on to win as all our momentum had gone well before their goal.

As it was the penalty sparked us back into life and we could just as easily have won it as them by the end.

Just one point is the bizarre substitutions today. Firstly bringing Zoum (who I like) on for our best player Baxter and then taking off Akins (who wasn't having a great game admittedly) for a defender in Kay.

I know at 1-1 he wanted to defend a draw but as I said we picked up after the equaliser and the timing was bad. The final sub of Tiryaki for Enoch in the 86th minute was 20 minutes too late.

Man of the Match was Baxter but special mention to Ash Taylor, Ian Goodison, Enoch Showunmi and in the first half especially Joss Labadie.

Once again the Charlton fans tried to referee the game and for the second year running it appears to have done the job!

A great day out and a great point though!

At Preston, we went for the game at 1-1 and lost. He brought on Kay to give us better defensive cover.

It was the wrong time in my opinion but we live and learn!

Still looks as inconclusive as it did at the time. Will wait for the highlights on Monday!

It's impossible to formulate an opinion from what they showed on the Football League show and even more mysterious was that they didn't ask or include either managers' opinion on the incident.

Quote:

@gony

Quote:

Hoots Mon

Quote:

@gony

Quote:

Hoots Mon
Sounds as tho we're doing well !

Say it as you SEE it.

think you may be trying to make a point ! tho not clear ! you don't see sounds ! you hear them, is that too complicated for you to undersatand ?

No,my previous reply was purely in words of one syllable so that YOU would understand.

We're, possibly, and doing both have two !!! why make yourself look so daft ? well done on spelling Syllable correctly tho !!! shame you have no idea what on is tho

Which word of 'Say it as you see it' has more than one syllable?
The other bit is what YOU said at 1523hrs during the match [not my reply] which also shows that you weren't there.

Good point Hoots Mon. We played well today, obviously. However as I said at half time, we are a team of two halves and will have to defend well. You are absolutely right, we need to score goals. We can moan justifiably at the ref however goals would negate his actions. I actually believe that bad referee decisions balance out over a season, all teams get them.

at this rate then we will be owed a huge amount of ref decsios come january for the second half of season

Charlton looked pretty average because we kept breaking up their play and wouldn't let them build. We're progressing well. We've got shape and we're behaving like a team. All we need now is a bit of luck and time will do the rest. If we can avoid any major injuries that side should hit form round about Christmas. Just in time for the run in. An indication of how far we've come became clear to me when I found last seasons Tranmere calendar in drawer. Out of the 11 players on it only Goody and Ash Taylor still play for us.

I could not get to the game but the radio broadcast of the match suggested that we were quite prepared to take the game to Charlton. Our lack of strike power is more concernibg than the decisions of referees. There are some refs that are influenced by home supporters and a few that give 50/50 decisions to bigger clubs. I do not, however believe that the majority of refs are anti Rovers. If decisions are due to errors then over time these should balance out.
Yesterday was a good result especially with key players still out.
It should give encouragment for the Oldham game, which may define our season.A win following yesterday will be apointer that we are ateam that is beginning to take shape. More points dropped would in contrast suggest that it will bre a season of inconsistency.

We seem to play better away from home and perhaps it suits our style of play better. We seem to be a more balanced side when the opposition come at us more and leave the spaces that we are able to utilise when we break.
I wonder what side will turn up against Oldham on Saturday? and will Robbo be fit for that match?

Quote:

@gony

Quote:

ivvy

Quote:

Matt34
Yes Di Canio, went public and said he would tell his players to dive, because he didn't get a penalty he thought he should have in a recent match.
Frankly he should be warned by the FA for admitting to the potential promotion and use of unfair gamesmanship.

I wonder if he will ring Martin Allen and ask for tips on cheating?

Heard the bloke from Tranmere who guests along Radio Merseyside commentator.
He said a player of ours , knowing that there was someone behind, let his body go limp so he would fall on contact.
Is that what they do ?

"Heard the bloke from Tranmere" bleadin el is this the cowsheds ?

Is! that! all! you! have! to! say?

Words of one syllable only

Now I know why it asked me to type the code twice.

Quote:

Hoots Mon
Now I know why it asked me to type the code twice.

YEAH YEAH, it's true ! I'm a@#$%&supporter and not entitled to post on here coz I never went the Game saturday ! so sick ! I've been found out ! pleased Namimbia got the win tho ! ha !

Quote:

ivvy

Quote:

@gony

Quote:

ivvy

Quote:

Matt34
Yes Di Canio, went public and said he would tell his players to dive, because he didn't get a penalty he thought he should have in a recent match.
Frankly he should be warned by the FA for admitting to the potential promotion and use of unfair gamesmanship.

I wonder if he will ring Martin Allen and ask for tips on cheating?

Heard the bloke from Tranmere who guests along Radio Merseyside commentator.
He said a player of ours , knowing that there was someone behind, let his body go limp so he would fall on contact.
Is that what they do ?

"Heard the bloke from Tranmere" bleadin el is this the cowsheds ?

Is! that! all! you! have! to! say?

allways better than saying too much !!!!!

Quote:

Deadly Submarine
Still looks as inconclusive as it did at the time. Will wait for the highlights on Monday!

Looking at it on the BBC website this morning, it's still totally inconclusive-two Charlton players in a heap on the floor but no obvious movement from either/any of the Tranmere defenders next to them.

I followed the game on soccer saturday and Aidy Boothroyd seemed to give us a lot of praise, so happy the lads put in a good performance.

I think the point about us being better or more suited to playing away is a valid one. When the onus is on us to attack teams we struggle massively, and the fans get frustrtaed. This becomes worse when we don't have any cutting edge up front, particularly when Robbo is out.

If we had a real goal threat, and started to convert the chances we seem to be creating we look capable of finishing at least top half, maybe even higer. Unfortunately the struggle to score goals will cost us this season, as you cannot rely on the defence to constantly keep clean sheets.

it's not just Robbo, it's also Devaney. He's a pretty big player too. Even if he had been playing the past few games, I think another 2-3 points might have been bagged.

Then I ate his Liver.......... with some baked beans and a can of coke.

ah the goals will come ! not worried ! amount of attempts on goal away to the top side ! excellent !
Watched the pen ! three of them hit the dack at once ! can't beleive the Ref fell for it ! tozzer

not so happy with the way powell basically called us rubbish on the football league show "teams like them will come here and timewaste" dont make me laugh you idiot and well done the lads . ps i hate neil mellor.

Owain Fon Williams did a lot of time wasting in fairness but it happens all the time to the same extent so to complain seems strange.

Since when does 10 shots off target, 8 on target for the away side, versus 2 on target and 4 off target for the home side mean that a lot of time wasting was going on. If only we had a Muir or aldridge we'd be near the top on those sort of stats.