Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
By Tyne-Talk
April 17 2010
Wayne Routledge, who made the Coca Cola Championship team of the week this week, came out top in the Tyne-Talk poll "Which of our new signings/players do you think will have the biggest impact upon our push for re-entry into the Premier League?" Routledge received 64% of the vote miles ahead of 2nd place Mike Williamson.
With 271 votes cast in total, Danny Simpson who was previously voted by Tyne-Talk readers as the player they most wanted to be signed up after a loan spell, came in 3rd place with 10%.
What Do You Think? Did Wayne Routledge have the biggest impact on your promotion bid or do you think one of the other new players/signings played a bigger part?
Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: TyneTalk (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 18:40
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: Robby Bobson (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 19:09
Yes, not entirely because of the impact he made, but it meant Guthrie could move into the middle and dominate games.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: MissC (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 19:14
Welcome to the site

Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: wasim4nufc (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 19:52
Quote:Robby Bobson
Yes, not entirely because of the impact he made, but it meant Guthrie could move into the middle and dominate games.
Totally agreed. Welcome to the forum!


Wasim's Sport Blog
Toon4life
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: Mighty__Mag (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 21:03
Didnt like him at first, and still think he hoggs the ball a bit and forgets to play simple passes, but the amount of assists he has is very good,


Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: TOONTILLIDIE (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 21:09
Quote:wasim4nufcQuote:Robby Bobson
Yes, not entirely because of the impact he made, but it meant Guthrie could move into the middle and dominate games.
Totally agreed. Welcome to the forum!
Welcome to the site Robson, fully agree with you and Wasim, with Routledge we have added pace to our team and will more dangerous in the counter attack game especially in the premiership as well as having Guthrie in the middle, we have somebody that can actually pass the ball.
I thought when we went after Williamson that it was a massive mistake, and thought what the hell are club wasting money. He has been great so far, but the premiership will be a test and will be a squad player. But with the injury to Taylor he is another that had kept us on track for the road back.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: waffles (IP Logged)
Date: 17/04/2010 23:04
He's balanced the flanks to the point that our attacks can be generated on either side of the pitch, moved Guthrie to the middle which and has improved our attacking ability. Furthermore, he's provided cover on the Right Flank for Simpson. Opposing sides were able to push our right side harder than the left, because the ball could be picked up at midfield instead of the box.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: Biffins Bridge (IP Logged)
Date: 18/04/2010 01:58
Ive been so impressed with Williamson who has just got straight on with things but Routledge has really made a big impact for all the points above.
A couple of goals with numerous assists and the best of all for the premiership.... pace.
A couple of goals with numerous assists and the best of all for the premiership.... pace.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: bully76 (IP Logged)
Date: 18/04/2010 14:23
i think it is a close call between him and williamson.
mike has slotted in excellent with colocini when we lost steven taylor to injury.routledge has stopped us being so predictable.everything use to just go down the same wing with jonas.now we can attack both flanks and routledge offers us pace.like people have said it has given guthrie a chance to move into middle where he has impressed,guthrie was shocking on the wing and dont want to see him there again.he offers alot more than smith or butt.like the midfield of guthrie nolan routledge and jonas.
mike has slotted in excellent with colocini when we lost steven taylor to injury.routledge has stopped us being so predictable.everything use to just go down the same wing with jonas.now we can attack both flanks and routledge offers us pace.like people have said it has given guthrie a chance to move into middle where he has impressed,guthrie was shocking on the wing and dont want to see him there again.he offers alot more than smith or butt.like the midfield of guthrie nolan routledge and jonas.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: lostmekeys (IP Logged)
Date: 18/04/2010 20:00
i like that midfield four as well bully, would hope any signings in that area would be intended to start though,orat the very least push those four to keep playing at their best. there are bound to be injuries, so we certainly need to add at least one central midfielder and a winger/wide midfielder
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: waffles (IP Logged)
Date: 18/04/2010 21:26
Quote:lostmekeys
i like that midfield four as well bully, would hope any signings in that area would be intended to start though,orat the very least push those four to keep playing at their best. there are bound to be injuries, so we certainly need to add at least one central midfielder and a winger/wide midfielder
We could definitely use a left footer. Lovenkrands gives cover for Jonas and played well on the left flank last season, but after his goal scoring form this season, I'd prefer to see him up top as he gives us some much needed pace there. It'd be nice to have another Left Mid so that Jonas can play on the right side occasionally.
That said: In a 4-5-1, Jonas, Guthrie, [new CM], Lovenkrands with Nolan in the hole could be dangerous. Routledge off the bench can come on for Loven, Jonas, or the striker as Jonas can switch flanks and Loven can play up top.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010:04:18:21:37:47 by waffles.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: TOONTILLIDIE (IP Logged)
Date: 18/04/2010 21:43
Quote:wafflesQuote:lostmekeys
i like that midfield four as well bully, would hope any signings in that area would be intended to start though,orat the very least push those four to keep playing at their best. there are bound to be injuries, so we certainly need to add at least one central midfielder and a winger/wide midfielder
We could definitely use a left footer. Lovenkrands gives cover for Jonas and played well on the left flank last season, but after his goal scoring form this season, I'd prefer to see him up top as he gives us some much needed pace there. It'd be nice to have another Left Mid so that Jonas can play on the right side occasionally.
That said: In a 4-5-1, Jonas, Guthrie, [new CM], Lovenkrands with Nolan in the hole could be dangerous. Routledge off the bench can come on for Loven, Jonas, or the striker as Jonas can switch flanks and Loven can play up top.
Ideally we would sign a creative midfielder but we know they are going to be hard to find on the money that we have got as well as we need to strengthen in other positions.
But if we did go for the 4-5-1, then maybe we could sign a left winger and then play Jonas in the midfield in the creative role, he likes to run, he is quick, can pass a ball and wins loads of free kicks.
We would then have cover as Jonas or Lovernkrands could to the left or right wing.
Re: Did Routledge Have The Biggest Impact Over Other Signings?
Posted by: tunyc (IP Logged)
Date: 19/04/2010 18:54
Yes!
Welcome to the site, Bobson & Bully!
You make good points-Routledge's impact has been huge. He's an improvement to the squad in and of himself and he's allowed wor Danny to move the middle of the park where he's been a revelation.
I do hope he works on his finishing in the offseason.
(And Williamson is a close second for me. I'm quite pleased to have been proven wrong about him...)
Welcome to the site, Bobson & Bully!
You make good points-Routledge's impact has been huge. He's an improvement to the squad in and of himself and he's allowed wor Danny to move the middle of the park where he's been a revelation.
I do hope he works on his finishing in the offseason.
(And Williamson is a close second for me. I'm quite pleased to have been proven wrong about him...)
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
