Player Ratings v Everton (H)
By Wasim
November 5 2011
Captain Fabricio Coloccini has been named Man of the Match by Tyne-Talks resident player rater Wasim4nufc for his part in today's 2-1 win against Everton. Ryan Taylor, who scored a great goal and Danny Guthrie also picked up high scores in the lunchtime kick off. Read on to see how the rest of the team faired....
Player Ratings
Tim Krul (7) - Hardly had that much to do in all honesty although his handling was top draw.
Danny Simpson (7) - Allowed Rodwell to beat him to the ball for their goal but apart from that he contributed to the win today with some good defending. He also provided the cross which led to the opener.
Steven Taylor (7.5) - Played Saha onside in one moment of poor decision making but won a lot in the air and did well generally.
Fabricio Coloccini (8.5) - Outstanding display by our skipper. He won some vital challenges, dealt calmly with some situations when calmness was required and looked our best player today.
Ryan Taylor (8) - Had a difficult time marking Drenthe although there were times he defended well too. Scored what turned out to be the winner with a superb strike worthy of winning the match.
Sylvain Marveaux (7) - Wasn't in the game that much although he did show some glimpses of what we can expect when he gets a chance in the team. Worked hard and won the ball a few times although unfortunately for him he picked up an injury which could be serious considering he has a history of having groin problems.
Danny Guthrie (8) - I thought he was outstanding in the middle of the park. Kept possession well, got stuck in and kept going right up until the end. Seems to be relishing his chance in the team.
Yohan Cabaye (6.5) - Formed a nice partnership with Guthrie before having to go off injured just after we made it 2-0.
Jonas Gutierrez (7) - In terms of work rate he was excellent again. Helped out the back line on quite a few occasions. Hardly attacked today but I think what today showed is that he should always play on the left.
Demba Ba (7) - Worked hard without really getting many opportunities today. Came deep a few times and again was more effective than Best.
Leon Best (7) - Put in a good shift without getting any opportunities to have a shot at goal. Played his part in unsettling Everton which led to us winning the game in the first half.
Substitutes
Dan Gosling (7) - Did fairly well when coming on considering he has hardly featured at this level for the last 18 months. Made some good challenges although he was fortunate not to be penalised for handling the ball in the box. Will no doubt get better if given more game time.
Sammy Ameobi (7.5) - I enjoyed his cameo. Made some decent runs, helped out defensively and held up the ball with his unique style. Does seem a bit raw still but that's expected of someone his age.
Hatem Ben Arfa (7.5) - Did his job nicely when coming on. Held up the ball, won fouls and played the clock down which was what we needed to clinch the victory.
Newcastle United Man of the Match - Fabricio Coloccini
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
I would have went for Raylor as man of the match, not just because he scored a stunning goal but thought he did well
Not sure why Cabaye's mark is so low. Surely we can't judge him on getting injured?
I also thought Gosling was less than completely effective after coming on and on another day, he's conceded a penalty: 5-5.5 for me.
Gosling has been out for a while and probaly was trying to prove something with eventually getting a game and playing against a ex team, given enough games he will come good but suppose options are going to limited as Tiote and Cabaye are first choice and Guthrie has done well since coming back into the team